[comp.sys.ibm.pc] To Window or not to Window

battle@umbc3.UMBC.EDU (Rick) (05/24/89)

Imagine you have been promoted to the position of
Workstation Administrator by your organization.  You are
expected to bring your considerable technical skills to bare
on several problems experienced by the thousands of
workstations (PC's) in your organization.  For the purpose
of this discussion PC's are 286 or 386 IBM compatible
machines.
Here is one of the problems.  A Chief Administrator or Dean
is stuck on Windows 286 or Windows 386.  He says buy the
prouduct.  You have to decide the following;
 
1. What compatibility exists between Windows and
Presentation Manager?  In other words, if you buy Windows
now and OS/2 takes off two or three years from now will you
have to trash your investment in Windows and be demoted back
to your present position, give up your free parking and
secretary.
 
2. Windows 286 does no multitasking, DESQview does.  What
arguement do you make in favor of a non-Windows product?
You may include Omniview if you like or any other product.
But remember, you have to convince NON-TECHNICAL PEOPLE WHO
MAKE THE ULITMATE DECISION!!!
 
3. Windows 386 does the virtual 8086 mode.  What TSR
problems exist?  Are they worth the hassle?  What do you
tell the big cheese?
 
4. Beyond buying Mac II's for everybody, what other
alternatives are there?
 
Although this may sound like a ton BS to most of you, they
are real questions being asked by "the big cheeses"
everywhere who read the crap in the trade rags and don't
want to hear bits and bytes arguements.  How many times have
you seen eyes glaze over when you were trying to explain
something important to a non-techincal type?
 
Anyhow if you have any interest, let the brainstroming fly
and if the content is worth repeating it will be brought
before netland for further review.
 
Have a good holiday and remember next week is, worst case, a
four day week!
 
Cheers...

rogerson@PEDEV.Columbia.NCR.COM (Dale Rogerson) (05/26/89)

	If the programs you want to run happen to be Window's applications,
like Excel, Pagemaker, etc, then Windows is better than any of the other
environments.  However, I would not recommend Windows if your main functions
are programming, or working with large DOS only programs.  It also depends
on the knowledge of the users running the system.  DESQview is better 
for running DOS applications, but it can be a pain to get things working 
the first time with your application.

-----Dale
	Rogerson-----

mms00786@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu (05/31/89)

Windows does do multitasking. It simply doesn't do pre-emptive multitasking.

Milan
mms00786@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu