[net.movies] ST2: Kirk incompetent

dssg (06/22/82)

As to Kirks competence, other than not raising his shields faster when the
Reliant was behaving mysteriously (although the half quoted regulation
may have something to do with that) and the beaming down of top officers
into hazerdous areas (with or without armed escort consisting of 1 or 100
men), but that's Star Trek tradition, he made, in my opinion, militarily
speaking, sound decisions.
                                               Ralph, again.

hansen@sri-unix (06/23/82)

I believe it was clearly implied (by the half-quoted regulation)
that when performing a rendevous with a ship that refuses communication
or is apparently unable to communicate, the regulations require
that the shields be raised.  I don't suppose that Star Fleet Command
intends to censure our hero for bungling it, however.