bukys (12/26/82)
"The Dark Crystal" - has nice puppetry. The major characters ("Gelflings") are an unfortunate exception: their faces are barely articulated. - has visual beauty. The minor characters and the scenery are wonderfully alive. - is a not a children's story, adult's story, or anybody's story. The scriptwriters have much to learn about fiction in general and fantasy in particular. *Choice* is the vital element of anything resembling a battle of good and evil. "The Dark Crystal" plows through its plot without a single character making a decision. It is completely "event-driven", so to speak. It may be that the technical people forgot that effects should be subordinate to plot. - is a "children's story", if by that you mean that children require that the plot be transparent and without depth. Everything that might have been a surprise is given away twice, just in case you missed it the first time. A good children's story, on the other hand, opens up a world-sized world, not a lunchpail-sized world (and without the condescension of making the plot easy). - is not "Tolkienesque". Why is it that anything with a pointed ear and no high technology is "Tolkienesque"? Tolkien did not invent the fantasy genre. Please don't pick on him by claiming every piece of fluff is on a par with his (sub)creation. ~= ;-} ~= All in all, nice to watch, but go to the cheap matinee. I will be waiting eagerly for a similar production of some *real* fantasy fiction. Liudvikas Bukys ...!seismo!rochester!bukys
lsk (12/28/82)
I agree -- the dark crystal is VISUALLY fascinating , but the plot is TOTALLY lacking. About all I can say is that anyone who thinks the plot of the Dark Crystal is good knows NOTHING about your basic sci-fi plot. And, even with that, it is stated at the very beginning that the Gelfling is fated to return the the shard to the crystal. And he does. And in a not even very interesting way, either. Big deal. Definitely wait for it to come to the cheap show places because the visuals are somewhat interesting. But that's about it. -Larry S. Kaufman Western Electric, Network Software Center