[comp.sys.ibm.pc] 2 disk controllers?

fordke@ingr.com (Keith Ford x8614) (02/28/90)

Quick question...
I know you cannot have two disk controllers in a PC, but can you have one
for the floppies and one for the hard disk?  I see controllers which are
for hard disk only which doesn't seem logical if my first sentence is
strictly true.
-- 
_____________________________________________________________________
 Internet:  fordke@ingr.com   \   "and the Trees are all kept equal
 UUCP:  ...!uunet!ingr!fordke  \   by hatchet, axe, and saw." -Rush

mlau@hpspcoi.HP.COM (Mel Lau) (03/01/90)

????
What is the problem ??
You can have a floppy disk controller and a hard disk controller.
You are probably thinking that you can not have 2 hard disk controllers.
This is true, but only due to the nature of the ROM bios and/or O/S.
For example, Unix for 386 machines, do not use the ROM bios and
can support 2 hard disk controllers.


*Mel

hchen@silver.ucs.indiana.edu (H. Chen) (03/02/90)

In article <1640065@hpspcoi.HP.COM> mlau@hpspcoi.HP.COM (Mel Lau) writes:
>????
>What is the problem ??
>You can have a floppy disk controller and a hard disk controller.
>You are probably thinking that you can not have 2 hard disk controllers.
>
>*Mel

I am not the person who asked this question.  But I am curious to get
the answer.  And I have a question related to this.

My friend have a two floppy disk drivers, both for 5.25" disk.  I helped
to add a harddisk with a controller card.  It works.  Now, if he wants to
replace one of his 5.25" disk driver into a 3.5" one, does he need another
disk driver controller card for 3.5 driver?  (Someone suggested here that 
simply replacing a 5.25" drive with a 3.5" one will only give 360k capacity 
for the 3.5" drive.)

So, can we have 2 floppy disk controller cards?

Thank you in advance for giving the answers.

--che

bobmon@iuvax.cs.indiana.edu (RAMontante) (03/02/90)

hchen@silver.ucs.indiana.edu (H. Chen) <37589@iuvax.cs.indiana.edu> :
-replace one of his 5.25" disk driver into a 3.5" one, does he need another
-disk driver controller card for 3.5 driver?  (Someone suggested here that 


I successfully replaced my 5.25" B:  drive with a 3.5" drive in a 1985
vintage xt-compatible, with no controller change.  I use MSDOS v3.21,
and my CONFIG.SYS file includes the line:

	drivparm=/d:1 /f:2 /h:2

I couldn't do this to the A: drive, because the BIOS and controller can't
handle the 3.5" drive on their own (so they can't ever load the o.s. and
CONFIG.SYS).  But it works with no problem for my B: drive.

Umm...  I'm talking about a 720K 3.5" drive.  I believe this will _not_
work for a 1.44M 3.5" drive.

feustel@well.sf.ca.us (David Alan Feustel) (03/04/90)

PCs can support two controllers. Most controllers have a jumper which
selects either the primary or secondary disk controller address. The
problem is that the bios does not support having a second controller.
Anna Books sells C source for IBM PC and AT compatible bios programs
which can be modified to support second floppy/hard disk controllers.
Anna Books advertises in many PC magazines in the classified
sections.

mep@stb.uucp (???) (03/05/90)

In article <37589@iuvax.cs.indiana.edu> hchen@silver.ucs.indiana.edu (H. Chen) writes:
>In article <1640065@hpspcoi.HP.COM> mlau@hpspcoi.HP.COM (Mel Lau) writes:
>>????
>>What is the problem ??
>>You can have a floppy disk controller and a hard disk controller.
>>You are probably thinking that you can not have 2 hard disk controllers.
>>
>>*Mel
>
>I am not the person who asked this question.  But I am curious to get
>the answer.  And I have a question related to this.
>
>My friend have a two floppy disk drivers, both for 5.25" disk.  I helped
>to add a harddisk with a controller card.  It works.  Now, if he wants to
>replace one of his 5.25" disk driver into a 3.5" one, does he need another
>disk driver controller card for 3.5 driver?  (Someone suggested here that 
>simply replacing a 5.25" drive with a 3.5" one will only give 360k capacity 
>for the 3.5" drive.)
>
>So, can we have 2 floppy disk controller cards?
>
>Thank you in advance for giving the answers.
>
>--che

You failed to mention the type of machine... that is AT, XT or ??? I
just installed a 1.4meg 3.5" drive on my AT. My system has an NCL
Hard disk/Floppy disk controller with two hard disks and two
floppies attached. I now have a 1.2 meg 5.25 and a 1.4meg 3.5
working flawlessly... bite my tongue... It was plug & play since my
bios supports both.

marty

feustel@well.sf.ca.us (David Alan Feustel) (03/08/90)

It's common practice to have one 5.25" and one 3.5" floppy drive
connected to a single controller. You need DOS 3.3 to do this. Your
3.5" drive will read/write 720/1440 k diskettes with no problem.
-- 
Phone:	 (home) 219-482-9631 
E-mail:	feustel@well.sf.ca.us		{ucbvax,apple,hplabs,pacbell}!well!feustel	
USMAIL: Dave Feustel, 1930 Curdes Ave, Fort Wayne, IN 46805