[comp.sys.ibm.pc] IDE: Insufficiently Detailed Explanation?

clear@actrix.co.nz (Charlie Lear) (03/22/90)

In article <25100002@adaptex> neese@adaptex.UUCP writes:
>I would not suggest anyone avoids SCSI.  I would rather say, that you should
>be intelligent about choosing SCSI.  SCSI is not for everyone.  Selecting
>the peripherals can be a chore.

I've been waiting for someone from Adaptec to show their head above the
trench... 8-)

One thing I've never been able to figure out is IDE interface drives.
Everyone is able to tell me that the drive controller is built onto the
drive and it uses a simple host adaptor.

I've been trying to get Miniscribe 8051A's and Quantum Pro-40's running
with a Taiwanese 12MHz AT motherboard with AMI BIOS, and have had no end
of hassles.  The Miniscribes (all four of them that we tried) reported
faulty drive, faulty controller, or invalid drive specification, despite
the fact that all four worked perfectly in our 8MHz IBM AT testbed.
Someone at Melco (our local Miniscribe supplier) said that we might have
bought old versions of the drive.  One Quantum has worked well in a
variety of machines, but when a second drive was daisychained in the
approved manner, it reported seek errors galore and the second
drive overheated and died within an hour (just long enough for me to
transfer all my word processing data subdirectories onto it).

There's a growing number of machines and motherboards being supplied
with IDE adaptors built in, and since it appears to be an option growing
in popularity, I've tried to find out as much as I can about it.
Trouble is, I've been able to turn up absolutely nothing on the subject.
Is there a reference somewhere that simply describes IDE technology, and
how the drives are arranged?  For instance, are adaptors interchangable?
Can you daisychain different makes of IDE drive?  

I'd be grateful if you could throw any light on the above, and
absolutely grovellingly in your debt forever if you could assist with
the 8051A/Quantum probs.  (I've gone back to an MFM (ugh!) controller
and Miniscribe 3085 drive until I get the IDE thing sorted.)

Regards
 Charlie Lear

-- 
 Charlie "The Bear" Lear:  Call The Cave BBS, 64(4)643429 157MB Online!
             Home of the World Famous KiwiBoard BBS Software!
        Snail: P.O. Box 12-175, Thorndon, Wellington, New Zealand
                 All mail and flames to clear@actrix.co.nz