[comp.sys.ibm.pc] 1.44M vs 720K floppy compatibility

rt@lexicon.com (Robert Tillman) (05/04/90)

Since 1.2M and 360k 5.25" floppies are somewhat compatible, I bought a
1.44 meg 3.5" floppy drive for my AT clone (12Mhz, AMI bios) thinking
that that I could use it transfer files between my machine and a
machine with a 720K drive.  I was wrong!  When I try a "format /4" on
my machine, it responds with something like "drive doesn't support
this format".  When I try to read a disk formatted and written on a
machine with a 720K drive, I get the old "Abort, Retry, Fail?"
message.

Is it at all possible to do what I want to do?  Do some 1.44M drives
support 720K format, and others don't?  Is "/4" the right format
switch to use?  Is this a controller problem?  Should I give up?

Please email.  Will summarize + post if...etc.  Thanks for your help.

- Bob Tillman
rt@lexicon.com
...!harvard!spdcc!lexicon!rt

dale@wucs1.wustl.edu (Dale Frye) (05/05/90)

Original poster talked about formatting 720K disk in a 1.44M drive.
He was trying to use the /4 option.

The /4 option is for formatting 360K disks in a 1.2M drive ONLY!!!

You must have DOS 3.3 (or 3.2???) or DOS 4.0 to do what you want.

In DOS 3.3
                FORMAT B: /T:80 /N:9

In DOS 4.0
                FORMAT B: /F:720
            or use 3.3 method.

I am of course assuming that drive B: is the 1.44M drive.

Another related problem with adding 1.44M drives is that older 
machines do not support 1.44M in their BIOS. You must use
a driver (included with DOS 3.3 and 4.0).

Dale Frye

gribble@cica.cica.indiana.edu (gribble) (05/07/90)

1st, read the DOS manual it explains all of this quite clearly.
the correct line should be format b: /n:9 /t:80;  this formats
a 720kb disk in a 1.44mb drive (pages 7-128-129 IBM DOS Reference V3.30).

-- 
************************************************************************
* Steve Gribble                  Internet: gribble@cica.cica.indiana.edu
* Lead Computer Consultant                 swg@iumail.ucs.indiana.edu
* Dept. of Sociology, Indiana University   Bitnet:   gribble@iubacs