[net.movies] Trek III inconsitency

sdh@rabbit.UUCP (Yah Right ) (06/05/84)

Ok here's a question for you people who've seen ST III:

When the bridge controls went dead, why didn't they go to auxilliary
control? There was still power enough to run the computer for the
self-destruct sequence, there was still enough juice for the elevator
to get them to the tranporter room, and there was enough power to 
transport them down to the planet, So why the hell didn't Kirk send
Scotty down to auxilliary to send one photon torpedo to blow the hell
out of the Klingon scout ship?
Don't try to convince me that there was no way you can launch things
other than the bridge, because Spock's coffin was blasted away from
the torpedo room (remember Scooty whaling on those bagpipes?)

Ooops! The Enterprise probably didn't have to be sacrificed.

"Life.. don't talk to me about life" -Marvin
Steve Hawley
<allegra,alice>!rabbit!sdh

gm@trsvax.UUCP (06/08/84)

#R:rabbit:-286300:trsvax:53700015:000:624
trsvax!gm    Jun  7 20:58:00 1984

It wasn't that the Enterprise had lost power, Scotty had implemented a new 
computer system to control the functions that the other 490 crew 
members had previously had contol over.	 Remember, he tells Kirk,
"Cap'n, I jury rigged this thing for a normal space voyage, I didn'
expect to go into combat". I seems it was O.K. for controlling the 
normal functions of the Enterprise, but wasn't designed to control
the phasers, photon torps, or evasive warp-speed maneuvers in addition
to the regular stuff. So it got overloaded and blew up.

					George Moore
					Tandy System Software
					...!allegra!convex!ctvax!trsvax!gm

daver@hp-pcd.UUCP (06/18/84)

If the Enterprise hadn't been destroyed on the Genesis planet they wouldn't
have had the theme for Star Trek IV - The Search for the Enterprise.

Dave Rabinowitz
hplabs!hp-pcd!daver