[comp.sys.apple] Horrifyingly buggy release of system 5.0 :)

SELLSWORTH@HMCVAX.BITNET ("Scott, part time fuzzy") (08/11/89)

  This is a kind of long semi-flame, semi-review of TML systems and thier
marketing attitude.  Whack 'n' now to avoid it.


  These are just observations.  I am a partially satisfied customer, and I am
interested in the experiences of any other netters.  I called TML systems the
other day about thier new Pascal for the //gs.  The kindly folks said that they
had not yet shipped (big surprise) due to bugs.  Unlike last time, however,
they were waiting on software from Apple.  They have claimed that thier
software has been done since early June, shading into July as thier August
release date appropached.  They told me that "Apple's new system software is
very buggy, so they are waiting for Apple to send them a bugless version."

  Does this sound like they are using one of the development versions of system
5.0, or are they merely trying to cover thier inability to get a product out on
time?  In other word, those of you from Apple, is this reasonable?  I tend to
boubt, because ,to my knowledge, they have never met a release date, or even
been within a month and a half of an expected release date.)  In short, has
anyone had any favorable experiences with them regarding releasing thier
products to the outside world?

  A side note:I asked them if they ever intended to compete with the Byte Works
folks by offering desktop debuggers.  I was kind of thinking of Lightspeed
Pascal on the Mac, which offers friendly segmentation and decent project
management.  (Anyone who has tried to port a file from Unix that used a
makefile to manage the creation of one code file from a dozen source files
knows what I am talking about....)  Thier response was "We have not marketed
our product for those who might have need for a debugger.  In our experience,
only advanced programmers desire symbolic debugging tools and optimization.
Our product is for the starting programmer who would not need these features."
Hmmm.  I kind of like symbolic debuggers, especially when I am learning a
language.  Kind of gives you a chance to see what the machine is actually
doing.

  As I recall, Dave Lyons has done some very good work with TML Pascal, though
I have forgotten which version.  Has anyone else done significant amounts of
work with thier compiler (either version)?  I have done maybe a couple thousand
lines of code with the integrated version, and I see enough problems to worry
me.

  Flames to /dev/null, money to my bank account, and disclaimers to the hilt!

  Scott Ellsworth
  sellswor@jarthur.claremont.edu
  SELLSWORTH@HMCVAX