[comp.lang.prolog] this seems to have bounced back....

lyda@acsu.buffalo.edu (louis k lyda) (05/02/90)

i'm reposting this as it seems to have bounced back...
-----------------
thanks to all of you who told me about prolog interpreters for the ibm... but
i'm curious, no responses came from the us and a great number of articles on
comp.lang.prolog aren't from the us.... why? i'm just leaarning prolog and it
is by far one of the most interesting languages i've learned. i'm also
surprised that prolog isn't used as an introductory language, on a small level
it seems quite simple and can model everyday things with ease.... somehow
making a program that models "mary likes all animals except snakes." seems
more interesting than making a program that reads your name and then says
"hello, <name>."

any good reasons for this besides being hung up on von-neuman architecture and
unwillingness to change?

	kevin lyda@lictor.acsu.buffalo.edu

bradley@cs.utexas.edu (Bradley L. Richards) (05/03/90)

>thanks to all of you who told me about prolog interpreters for the ibm... but
>i'm curious, no responses came from the us and a great number of articles on
>comp.lang.prolog aren't from the us.... why?
>	kevin lyda@lictor.acsu.buffalo.edu

Probably because the bulk of the AI community in the U.S. is convinced that
Lisp is God's gift to mankind, and to use anything else is a sin.  The rest
of the world is somewhat more sensible....

I'd be interested in a summary of the responses you got.  I'm currently
looking at the LPA (Quintus) demo, and I except to get a copy of Arity
tomorrow to look at.  Turbo Prolog is ok for applications programming,
but hopeless for any meta-programming.  FWIW, the student price for the
Arity interpreter is $200, while the student price for the LPA "incremental
compiler" (read interpreter) is $381.  The compilers are extra in each
case.  If anyone is interested, I'll post benchmarks for the two.  I don't
have enough info to evaluate the relative features of the two, as the
PDA demo came with very limited information.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Bradley L. Richards       uucp:  cs.utexas.edu!bradley
 bradley@cs.utexas.edu     CompuServe:  75216,1744
---------------------------------------------------------------------------