[net.sf-lovers] Foundation's Edge

geo (10/17/82)

I saw the fourth novel in Issac Asimov's Foundation
series in the bookstore recently, and I just finished
reading it.

I am disappointed.  I am afraid that he is not nearly
as good a [fiction] writer as I remembered.  Throughout
the book I kept being reminded of something Jerry Pournelle
said in an interview when he was asked about 'The Golden
Age of Science Fiction'.  He said, "The golden age of
science fiction is whenever you were 13 years old."

Contrary to a prediction published on the net some months
ago, the novel at 365 pages was not appreciably longer
than the previous three novels.  Asimov wrote the first
three foundation novels over 20 years ago.  He had been
quoted as saying he would never write another as it would
be too difficult to introduce the readers to the background
from the previous novels.  Does anyone know why he changed his
mind?