rae@gpu.utcs.toronto.edu (Reid Ellis) (09/05/90)
Either sarima@tdatirv.UUCP (Stanley Friesen) or mjv@objects.mv.com (Michael J. Vilot) wrote: |The book 'with examples in C++' is *far* too caught up in a |Smalltalk style of OOD to be really useful for good C++ |programming. In <1197@fang.dsto.oz> dch@aeg.dsto.oz.au (Dave Hanslip) writes: |I assume this refers to "Object-Oriented Program Design with |Examples in C++" by Mark Mullin. I've seen this opinion expressed |before. Perhaps you could explain why. Right from the start, I should state I am not an expert on SmallTalk style OOD. I'll try to express what I perceive as the difference between SmallTalk and non-SmallTalk OOD. In a very general sense, there seem to be two methodologies when writing object-oriented software: the SmallTalk model and the not-SmallTalk model [NSM]. There may be a better name for the latter :-). The dividing line between this model and not-this-model is the existance of a unique base class, commonly called 'Object' or 'TObject' or something similar. Both NIHCL and MacApp follow the SmallTalk model, and I think Objective C does as well. The alternative with NSM is to have a number of non-unique base classes. The tradeoffs involve the overhead of creating a new [small] object which conceptually has no ancestors and the ability to use this object. In the SmallTalk model you can send this object any of a number of common messages, whereas this is not possible with the NSM model. However, the NSM object is small and carries no overhead. You could pass it on the stack if you like and feel comfortable with knowing roughly how efficient it is to do so. Not neccessarily so with the SmallTalk model. There are some caveats here, however. If the base Object only consists of methods/messages with no data, it is conceivable that its representation on the stack would be very small [type information] since methods may not really be instantiated for every object. Hope this ramble helps. Feel free to correct the above. Reid -- Reid Ellis 264 Broadway Avenue, Toronto ON, M4P 1V9 Canada rae@gpu.utcs.toronto.edu || rae%alias@csri.toronto.edu || +1 416 487 1383