[net.sf-lovers] Re Re The Force, or bad editing

cjh (01/04/83)

In response to your message of Tue Jan  4 00:12:02 1983:

   Your recollection does not match the production photos I recall seeing,
although that was quite a while ago.
   More important, it seems questionable that they would want to film with
a random noisemaker on-mike. (David Gerrold, in THE TROUBLE WITH TRIBBLES
(a book about the writing and shooting of that episode of STAR TREK), notes
that the moving tribbles were made by putting a tribble shell over the
works of a mobile toy dog, and that this meant that all the dialogue in those
scenes had to be looped in afterwards because of the noise made by the works.)
   Also, to be blunt, I just don't believe that you could get that much power
into a handle of that size. I'm familiar with what can be done with an
electric drill and find it implausible that you'd get anywhere near the
velocity with that size of shaft to cause significant frictional heating. The
handle would probably self-destruct first---or at least shake enough to give
the actor using it visible trouble (note how carelessly and easily Luke
handles the light-saber when introduced to it, and imagine doing the same
thing with a cat held by its tail).