[net.sf-lovers] 1984 & Animal Farm

ucbesvax.turner@ucbcad.UUCP (12/11/83)

#R:kobold:-21500:ucbesvax:8400004:000:1230
ucbesvax!turner    Dec 10 11:54:00 1983

Actually, "Animal Farm" is even more specific: it's clear to anyone
with some knowledge of the Russian Revolution that "Animal Farm" is
a precise allegory--to the point where one of the pigs just has to
be Leon Trotsky!  (Hey, I'll go along with him there...)

The other farms, to which the free animals first attempt to export
their revolution, later have their revolutions subverted by the
"leaders" (the pigs) of Animal Farm, who decide that their interests
are better served if outlying farms have human masters.  This an
allegory for Stalin's policy in Republican Spain--that a capitalist
European ally was preferable to one with a non-Russian-controlled
revolutionary government.  Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" makes this
connection unmistakable.

Orwell's point was *not* that communism and/or socialism degenerate
into totalitarianism.  "Animal Farm" is an indictment of Stalinism,
with a quizzical eye on Lenin, as well.  For a clearer exposition of
his real feelings about radical politics, read his nonfiction books.
Only then (I think) can his science fiction/fantasy/allegory novels
be read with some depth of understanding.  (Not that they can't be
enjoyed otherwise...)
---
Michael Turner (ucbvax!ucbesvax.turner)