[net.sf-lovers] The Menagerie

butenhof%SU-Shasta@orac.UUCP (12/27/83)

From:  Dave Butenhof <decwrl!rhea!orac!butenhof@SU-Shasta>

Hi there  -  considering  the number of ST fans that are probably out there,
the comment  I'm  addressing  has probably gotten tons of responses already;
but I might as well jump in.  After all, I just started getting this Digest,
so I have to join in SOMEWHERE . . .

Spock's "TIME  warp  7"  report  was  due  to  the primative state of the ST
universe at  the  time of The Menagerie (originally "The Cage").  There were
many other differences - you may have noticed that Majel Barrett was "Number
One", a  first-officer  with  the beginnings of the later Spock personality;
while Spock played a much more emotional character, and also looked somewhat
different than  later.   The "time warp" line would be one of many technical
differences you  could notice in the episode; it was simply changed later to
the "space warp" form which seemed to make more sense.

For anyone  who  might  not  know,  The  Menagerie was the original ST pilot
movie.  It  wasn't  bought,  since  it was too cerebral, and not very action
oriented.  Roddenbury came up with a more acceptable pilot, Where No Man Has
Gone Before,  and  later used both of them as episodes.  For the series, The
Menagerie was  split  into  a  two-parter:  even so, most of the really good
stuff was  cut  out.   I  had the opportunity to see the original movie at a
"World of  Star  Trek" show; I'm not sure I'd call it Star Trek, at least by
comparison with  the  ST  Universe  NOW,  but it was certainly a damned good
movie by any standards.