[sci.med] Answer to Medical Puzzle #21

werner@aecom.UUCP (Craig Werner) (11/17/86)

<>
> In a 'historical' case:
> 
> 	A young woman is brought into the emergency room in severe distress,
> pelvic pain, and profound shock.  An examination of the pelvic area reveals
> bloating, crepitus (gas trapped within the tissues), and a dark discoloration
> of the skin around the perineal (between the pubis and the anus) area.
> Aspiration of the subcutaneous space yields a brown-black liquid with a
> sickeningly sweet odor.  A culture of the liquid is sent off to confirm 
> the diagnosis. Aggressive treatment is started, although the chances 
> are very likely that the woman will die despite all effort.
> 
> 	1) What is the condition called?
> 	2) What is the cause of the condition?
> 	3) What is the cause of the condition?
> 		Note: #2 is a difficult question whereas #3 is straightforward.
> 	4) What, in a rough way, would treatment consist of?
> 	5) Why is this condition no longer commonly seen?

	The condition is called gas gangrene - the brown-black liquid is
necrotic and liquified tissue.  It is causes by the organism Clostridia
perfringens, to answer the first two questions.
	After that, there seemed to be some misunderstanding of the word
historical.  Most responders assumed historical to mean the last century,
and guessed that it was probably "childbed fever", a disseminated staph
infection (aka sepsis), but that would not produce local gangrene, and 
certainly not crepititus.  Where a staph sepsis would produce gangrene
is in the extremities (esp. fingers) where bacteria-immune complexes
lodged in small vessels and cut off circulation.  No by historical, I
was referring to prior to the early 1970s.
	That big hint given, the answer to 3 is easy.  The woman had
undergone a septic abortion.  This is the way it used to be done: induce
an infection of the pregnant uterus, the infection spread to the chorion,
and the fetus spontaneously miscarried.  If you were lucky, the placenta
was expelled completely.  If you were not, the portion of the retained
placenta became dead tissue in what was essentially an anaerobic environment,
a ripe target for secondary infection by such an anaerobic organism
as clostridia. This could also occur after a normal birth if part of
the placenta was retained (although less frequently because it was not
already infected.)
	Treatment would consist of treating the massive shock that 
accompanies the infection, debriding the necrotic tissue, fasciotomy
(removing the fascia, connective tissue, that the infection usually spreads
along), massive amounts of antibiotics (Clostridia is usually pencillin
sensitive), and possibly even hyperbaric oxygen.  Note that debridement
would most likely include removing the woman's entire reproductive tract.
Even with such drastic measures applied timely, the death rate was 
about 30-50%.
	
	It is probably obvious therefore why this condition is no longer
seen.  Therapeutic abortions are now legal (and the right to one for
the present time is constitutionally protected) and so women do not have
to resort to criminal (in many cases septic) abortions.  Making abortions
once again illegal would probably bring a resurgence of such cases, most
probably among the poor, the rich just taking a plane trip to Canada or
Europe as they did in the 1960s.

[Substantially correct guessea by Matt L. Fitchenbaum and Debbie Wolden.
 Joseph S.D. Yao was the only person to get both question #2 and #3 right.
 Those guessing childbed fever included Jerry Hollombe, Hank Buurman, and
 Michael C. Berch. 
 Other guesses included Toxic Shock Syndrome, PID due to tampons (thought
 I should note that it is Toxic Shock where tampons increase risk, not
 PID. PID is caused by Gonnorhea or Chlamydia and was increased by certain
 IUDs no longer marketed). Finally, there were suggestions of an overly
 tight chastity belt, or perhaps Coca-Cola.]



-- 
			      Craig Werner (MD/PhD '91)
				!philabs!aecom!werner
              (1935-14E Eastchester Rd., Bronx NY 10461, 212-931-2517)
           "My philosophy, like color TV, is all there in black and white."