[talk.philosophy.misc] Nonsense about the word 'infinte'

gsmith@garnet.berkeley.edu (Gene W. Smith) (11/21/88)

In article <1919@garth.UUCP>, smryan@garth (Steven Ryan) writes:

>Just a short note that is a mortal sin for a mathematician to say
>`inf***ty.' Penance usually is usually five Hail Davids.

  Nonsense. "F(x) as x --> +infinity" is the sort of thing
everyone learns in Calculus, which shows that even Freshmen can
understand what it means.

>The word `infinite' only occurs before `set,' `infinite set,' where it has
>a very precise meaning.

  More nonsense. "Let p be an infinite prime number in a
nonstandard model of arithmetic", "consider now the place at
infinity", "the proof follows the method of infinite decent",
"consider the infinite product prod_{p \in P} (1 - p^{-s})", all
taken from number theory alone.

>The correct term is `arbitrary.'

  As in "by arbitrary fiat, Ryan attempted to tell mathematicians
how they could use the word, 'infinite'". Alas, they all laughed.

  Beat it.
--
ucbvax!garnet!gsmith    Gene Ward Smith/Brahmsgangster/Berkeley CA 94720
                 "Your notation sucks!"  Serge Lang