[talk.politics.misc] Art vs. Pornography

rb@cci632.UUCP (Rex Ballard) (10/10/86)

Just for fun, I went through one of my old "art history"
books, and compared them to some of the current restrictions.

It seems that many of the great paintings of history would
be "X" rated if they were photographs, films, or live action.

One could argue that the nudes featured, full frontal in some
cases, was not intended to be arousing.  This is not the case.
Poetry and liturature of the same periods indicates that
these pictures were sexually arousing, even to the point
of appealing to the prurient interests of the viewer.

There seem to be two historical forms of censorship.

There is religious censorship, in which writing about
such things as "sex with spirits" (probably masturbation
fantisies) is repressed, often with such severe measures
as the spanish inquisition.  Performing acts prohibited
by the "kosher code" of the bible was similarly persecuted
as witchcraft, satanism, and heresy.

Political censorship seems to revolve around "live performance",
and simulations of live performance, such as photographs and
film.  At one time, the "Can-Can" was banned in France.
In the U.S., burlesque was the earliest constitutionally
accepted forms of censorship.  Photographs, film, and other
forms of technology have frequently been subject to tighter
restriction than either the printed word, or the oil painting.
Even the spoken word, in the form of radio broadcasts, is not
as severely restricted as the "life-like" action of television.

What is it about newer technologies that makes erotic depictions
so terrible?  Often, erotica has been a major factor in the early
survival and further development of these new technologies.
Animated film, such as the moviola, and projector owe their
economic backing to the "arcade peep show" of the turn of the
century.

Erotic paintings can be viewed in any museum, by children and
adults.  Films and photographs, depicting the same scenes,
can only be viewed in the back corners of a few drugstores
and newsstands, and is usually restricted to adults.