[mod.comp-soc] Economics and the selling of computers...

taylor@hplabsc.UUCP (Dave Taylor) (07/01/86)

--------
This article is from amd!amdcad!phil (Phil Ngai)
 and was received on Tue Jul  1 02:50:15 1986
--------

>The growth in inexpensive microcomputers in the
>United States is possible, in part, because the chips used for memory
>and processing are being built in places like Guatemala and the
>Philippines by low paid labor working in who knows-what kind of
>conditions.  My Macintosh at home is bought for a price that is not
>completely measured in dollars.  I am responsible for the effects
>(beneficial or otherwise) on people in small countries.

I don't think you are aware of the true situation or have thought this
through. American overseas manufacturing pays their foreign workers
very well, as compared to the general standard of living in the
country they are located in. It may be "low paid" by American
standards but you can not apply American standards. The cost of living
is much less. As long as the wages offered are at or above market
rates the companies are not doing anything wrong morally in my
opinion. It is not the role of American companies to change the world.
They are there to make money.  They have an obligation to treat their
workers fairly but they have no obligation to deal in charity.

The "natives" are usually quite eager to get a job working for the
Americans. Companies do not go out into the villages and round up
workers at gunpoint.  They just have to advertise high paid jobs in
air conditioned buildings and people are happy to leave their old jobs
pumping water or weeding fields by hand . And with their wages they
buy electric water pumps and such things. Everyone gains.

I must admit I work at a company with foreign operations. However, I
am not an official spokesman for my company. This article is merely my
personal opinion. I hope you can consider my words in an objective
light despite this.
-- 
 Phil Ngai +1 408 749 5720
 UUCP: {ucbvax,decwrl,ihnp4,allegra}!amdcad!phil
 ARPA: amdcad!phil@decwrl.dec.com