[net.auto.tech] Proper Needle Sizes for SU HS-4 Carbs. on Detoxed MGB et. al.

delbene@homxa.UUCP (K.DELBENE) (10/29/85)

A year or so ago, I detoxed my '79 MGB, removing the catlytic
converter and Zenith carb in favor of dual SU HS-4s and  a 
stainless exaust system.  Not wanting to go overboard, I left then
valve train in tact.  Well, last night I got to wondering about
the carbs' applicability with the stock pollution-control-influenced
valve train.  The question I have is whether the size 6 needles that
I put in are perhaps a bit too rich for the valve timing in the later model
Bs. I thought perhaps I'd try a number 21 instead.
Has anyone had experience with this modification?  Any recommendation
on needle sizes.  

While you're thinking about that one, try this one on for size: 
Sometimes when I accelerate hard off the line, I get a sharp knock
from the passenger side rear.  I've checked the brakes and spring shackles,
but nothing seems amiss.  I've had the problem since I bought the car 2 years
ago, but never experienced it on any other B's I've owned.  Having 
just had the car repainted 6 months ago, I told them to check for any frame
cancer, but the prognosis came back negative.  Anyone ever experienced such
a problem?

Any help  is much appreciated.  

					Kurt D. Del Bene
					Bell Labs - WB
					...!ihnp4!homxa!delbene

gxm@raybed2.UUCP (GERARD MAYER) (11/01/85)

On my '71 MGB with dual SU carb I can easily test if the mixture is too
rich by lifting the manual piston rod slightly while the engine is at idle.
If it is too rich the engine slows and does not return to the same idle 
speed. When it is just right the engine speed stays the same as I lift the
piston rod. I have found this to be a sensitive method with a little
practice. Noise: I had the same problem and in my car it turned out to
be the vapor collection canister in the trunk was loose enough to hit when
I took OFF!!!
						Gerry Mayer
						uucp  linus!raybed2!gxm

delbene@homxb.UUCP (K.DELBENE) (11/05/85)

On the point that one can lift the piston of the HS-4 carb. and check
the effect to determine whether or not the mixture is proper, you're 
right and you're wrong.  

For background in case anyone else cares, the SU, Stromberg, and Zenith
carbs are designed so that the needle is afixed to the end of a damping
piston.  When the throttle plate is open, the inrushing air causes the
piston to rise.  Since it is tapered, this in turn increases the amount
of fuel that mixes with the air.  The piston is dampered with an oil 
cylinder and piston arrangement, so that the changes in air/fuel ratio
are not so erratic.

Now, back to the point.  The test you do implies that you are starting with
the proper needle.  I don't think it will tell you if you have the proper 
needle for the characteristics of your engine.  That is the question that I've
raised.  It really belongs to a more general question: If one changes the 
characteristics of an engine, how do you find the best carburetion for the 
new set-up?  Other stories I've heard lead me to guess that my suspected 
problem of overcarburetion is quite common.

Another point on setting air/fuel mixtures in general: I've found this and
other methods very inexact for setting mixture.  About 6 months ago I bought
a tool called Colortune and have been very pleased with it.  It's really just
a see-thru spark plug with instructions on what color of flame you should be
seeing.  You simply richen out the carb and back up until the flame turns
bunsen blue.  It works fine on both single and multi-carb set-ups.  


					Kurt D. Del Bene
					Bell Labs - WB
					...!ihnp4!homxb!delbene