[net.games.board] Game suggestions results

clark@sdcsla.UUCP (Clark Quinn) (12/19/85)

A few weeks ago I posted a request for suggestions for two different types of
games.  I promised to summarize the results, so here they are.

For a strategy game for two the winner is (may I have the envelope please?):

PENTE.  This sounds like a version of 'go-moku'*, i.e. five in a row, but a
number of people said that this is a game that remains involving.  So, my SO's
parents are getting this game.
 (* but the board is different, apparently)

For a mystery solving game, One suggestion for "Sherlock Holmes: Consulting
detective" and one for "Consulting detective" make me think that that is/those
are the game(s) to get.  Whether they are one and the same, I don't know.  I
plan to find out, but since I already got my SO enough presents, that will
wait for another excuse to spend money.

Thanks to all who responded.  -- Clark

 Clark N. Quinn
 Institute for Cognitive Science C-015
 University of California, San Diego
 La Jolla, California 92093
 (619) 452-2541 (UCSD): (619) 457-1274 (Home)
 {ucbvax,decvax,akgua,dcdwest}!sdcsvax!sdcsla!clark  OR  clark@nprdc

bmg@mck-csc.UUCP (Bernard M. Gunther) (12/21/85)

> A few weeks ago I posted a request for suggestions for two different types of
> games.  I promised to summarize the results, so here they are.
> 
> PENTE.  This sounds like a version of 'go-moku'*, i.e. five in a row, but a
> number of people said that this is a game that remains involving.  So, my SO's
> parents are getting this game.
>  (* but the board is different, apparently)
>  Clark N. Quinn

The difference between go-moku and pente is not really in the board.  (Yes 
is a slight difference around the edge point, but it rarely comes into
play.)  The major difference is the following.  In go-moku you place stones
until either player has 5 in a row.  Pente you can win in either of two ways.
You can either get five in a row, or you can make 5 captures.  A capture
is done when one side has two stone next to each other and the other side
has a tone on each end.

            ..xxO..  ===>  .OxxO..  ==> .O..O..
             Start         O moves      resulting position.

This makes the game very much different than go-moku due to the fact that
pieces leave the board.  You have to pay closer attention to what is going
on and the game usually take less time to play05UUUUUUUUUUeUM1*.