kfl@AI.AI.MIT.EDU (01/05/87)
---------------------------------------- Date: Tue, 14 Oct 1986 10:40:03 EDT From: oswald!jim@ll-xn.ARPA Subject: Re: The 2nd Amendment Many people claim that the second amendment provides the general populace a constitutional right to keep and bear arms. This is demonstrably false. For many years, localities such as New York City have had laws which abridge this putative right. Many people have been convicted of violating these laws. During all this time, the Supreme Court has never overturned such a conviction due to conflict with the second amentment. If the Court really believed that such a right existed, the NRA would have found a suitable test case decades ago. The Court's silence speaks volumes. What the anti-gun-control people really mean is that *they* (not the Court) interpret the amendment to provide such a right. Anyone can interpret the constitution, but only the Court's interpretation really counts. By letting gun control laws stand, the Court has decided that a general right to keep and bear arms does not exist. -- Jim Olsen ---------------------------------------- Date: Tue, 14 Oct 2036 10:40:03 EDT From: oswald!foolwell@ll-xn.ARPA Subject: Re: The 1st Amendment Many people claim that the first amendment provides the general populace a constitutional right to say and write what they wish. This is demonstrably false. For many years, localities such as New Christ City have had laws which abridge this putative right. Many people have been convicted of violating these laws. During all this time, the Supreme Court has never overturned such a conviction due to conflict with the first amentment. If the Court really believed that such a right existed, the ACLU would have found a suitable test case decades ago. The Court's silence speaks volumes. What the anti-book-control people really mean is that *they* (not the Court) interpret the amendment to provide such a right. Anyone can interpret the constitution, but only the Court's interpretation really counts. By letting book control laws stand, the Court has decided that a general right to write whatever one wants does not exist. -- Jarry Foolwell ---------------------------------------- 'nuff said. ...Keith -------