[net.sf-lovers] In Defense Of Aldiss' Helliconia Trilogy

dht@druri.UUCP (TuckerDH) (02/03/86)

The Helliconia Trilogy is one of the best works to come out in the 
'80s. Aldiss stuck with a story line, or multiple story lines, and
his prose has rarely been better, showing his wonderful knack for
potent imagery and beautiful sentence structure, writing paragraphs
that roll off the page as if they were rolling off the tongue. 

Of the three (Spring, Summer, and Winter), "Helliconia Summer" is
by far the best. Not that the other two are bad, but "Summer" is
so well-written, so complex and rife with meaning, so evocative of
human events, that the other two pale by comparison. In "Helliconia
Summer", Aldiss presents us with a kind of Renaissance civilization,
filled with self-importance at its level of learning, still ignorant,
where tradition is being broken and adhered to with little rhyme or
reason. His characters live and breathe; you feel their exhalations
on your cheeks as you turn the page. His king is not so great, and
certainly not so good, for all that he is doing the right thing, and
his adversaries, such as his wife, are in much the same boat. This
is a common theme among his characters, that they do not have ironclad
solutions or infallible information, that often the right thing is done
for the wrong reasons, by the wrong person, and that just as often the
things that must be done in the world are so unpalatable that there is
no way that even a saint could dip his hands in the action and not become
soiled. 

Aldiss pays attention to his minor characters, also, reminding one of
Hugo, or Balzac, or Dickens, in that sometimes it is the minor characters
who are the most telling and the most memorable. His description of a 
world in much different climactic straights is never gone over to the
point of silly exposition, nor does he leave the reader wondering why
something is a certain way. Unfortunately, in "Helliconia Winter" too
much of the book is spent on this world-building, explaining it in relation
to Lovelock's Gaia Hypothesis. "Helliconia Winter" strikes a wonderful
balance, however.

His alien psychology is exceptional, unsurpassed. The native race of the
planet are creatures of intelligence ruled overwhelmingly by instinct.
The way in which they react to the dictates of environment is fascinating,
and intriguing in that the process is viewed from inside, not out. The 
other races that populate the planet are also well fleshed-out, their
differences and similarities drawn into a coherent whole. 

All three are worth reading, if only to make "Helliconia Summer" shine
even brighter as a set-piece. "Helliconia Spring" starts very slowly,
but builds up with majesty, power, and restraint, a perfect segue. Aldiss
is a writer who knows what makes human beings tick, what makes them love
and hate and persevere and quit, and it is a pleasure to read the works
of such a writer.

Davis Tucker