[net.nlang.india] Reply to Bajwa

murali@think.ARPA (Muralidhara Subbarao) (11/07/85)

Bajwa writes

>    	    The following memorandum was presented at the UN during 
>    its 40th anniversary celeberations by protesting Sikhs. It 
>    mostly talks about human rights violation against the Sikhs 
>    in India. .......
>
>    ..............................
>
>       Throughout their 500 year history, the Sikhs have 
>    stood for justice, human dignity, freedom of religion, 
>    respect for cultural diversity and for universal brotherhood 
>    and sisterhood.

     I do not know the 500 years of glorious history of the Sikhs.
   But I know that from 1981-84 the message that was emanating
   from the Gurudwaras of Punjab were not that of
    "universal brotherhood, sisterhood, blah.. blah blah..."
   but death squads with long "hit lists" seeking out
   political and community leaders, police officers,
   journalists etc.. Even innocent laymen travelling in
   buses were not spared. The acts of the "preachers" from
   Gurudwaras were splashed all over the news papers every day.

      The whole nation was held in a grip of terror by your
  "sants" hiding in the Golden temple. But they made the mistake
   of trying the patience of the nation for too long. Only the
   people of a tolerant religion like Hinduism can take it for
   so long. Do the sikhs dare try such stunts in islamic
   Pakistan? When the patience runs out, even the meekest
   fights back, then what of India? A small community cannot
   hold as large a nation as India for ransom, not for too
   long, not anymore (thank god!).

      Bhindranwale and his followers were clearly given a
   chance to surrender before the army was forced to enter
   the Golden "temple". But these people believed that they
   were invincible. It was a myth and they paid the price.
   They were asking for it and they deserved it. In a
   civilized world one should make use of appropriate forums
   to forward their cause. If Bhindranwale or anyone for that
   matter believes that they can subdue a civilization with
   their warrior skills or mythical supremacy they are wrong.

      Mr. Bajwa, you quibble about the damage and
   "desecration" of your temple by the Indian army. In your
   long winding thousands of lines of passages you never
   addressed the core of the matter which were rightly
   pointed out by many on the net.

     What were all these "guardians" of the Sikh religion
   who are protesting to the UN doing when Bhindranwale and
   his gang had occupied the Golden temple. What? WHAT? WHAT?
   Every sikh leader including the head priests were scared of
   Bhindranwale. Even Longowal's life was in threat by these
   people. By the time the army entered the Golden temple,
   it was no more a temple, it was a bunker with a bunch of
   cowardly criminals hiding inside.

     Mr. Bajwa, if you ever write again, first enlighten us about
   how your temple could remain holy with such a lot of arms and
   ammunition and most of all with people inside who were
   masterminding the murders of journalists, police, and
   most importantly innocent people and further more threatining
   the lives of some of their own men (the sikhs).

     Civilized sikh people should be grateful to the army for it
  liberated the Golden temple from these dirty men.

      The Dehli massacre is deplorable, but the beastly instinct
  in me says that it sent an unforgettable message to the sikhs:

          "for all your past (1981-84) atrocities, 
           you can't go scot free;
           you must pay the price, whatever your mythical
           superiority be."

  Now any sikh can imagine what awaits his community if he takes
  an oath in a Gurudwara to kill Rajiv.  
      
  For a long time to come, sikhs will be looked at with suspicion,
  even abroad.

    Mr.Bajwa, you rationalize the crimes of your men with
  long essays. So can the Indian governmet's actions be. But,
  alas, you are at an advantage, for you have lots of time.


   Mr. Bajwa, History will judge who was what and what was what,
   not us.


       May the god bless your people, and mine.


                                           murali.