[net.nlang.india] MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING

laha@uicsl.UUCP (11/17/85)

                                                                   1

                            MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING
                            ======================

               The brutal assassination of  Indira  Gandhi  and  the
          bloody  avenge  by some irate Indians have triggered a net
          debate which is gathering momentum as more of us are being
          dragged  into  the  vortex of this discussion.  It is true
          that the Indian army  attack  of  the  Golden  Temple  had
          undermined  the  religious pride of the Sikh community but
          definitely the temple was not in an impeccable holy  state
          when the 'sant' Bhindrenwala and his violent disciples had
          converted it into a bastion of arms  &  ammunition  and  a
          killing  squad of the visiting police officials and others
          who failed to see eye to eye with  the  'sant'.  Thus  the
          attack  of  the Golden Temple was an exorcising act, which
          was inevitable, if not overdue, and it  had  the  acquies-
          cence  of  the  majority  of  Indians.  But it was grossly
          unfair to make Mrs. Gandhi the target of  the  Sikh  wrath
          and  vendetta. The death reward she was handed over by her
          long trusted Sikh body guards had  outraged  most  of  the
          Indians,  presumably some of her party members, to espouse
          a transitory and an unfortunate macabre. But the  hue  and
          cry  which  was  made  and is still being made by the Sikh
          community ironically twisting the main issue and  cribbing
          about  the  gory  details  of  the  violence,  needs to be
          ignored.

               The post independent history of India is replete with
          bloody  riots.  The massacre in Assam, the sporadic commu-
          nal riots at Bombay, Bihar and other places, the attack on
          harijan  (a lower caste in India) at Maharastra, UP, etc.,
          and the last but not the least the pro-Khalisthani  gunmen
          have  spilled  more  bloods and claimed many more innocent
          Indian lives than the gory Indira  Gandhi  episode.   Just
          because  a  large  number of vociferous Sikhs are residing
          abroad and Punjab wants to captivate the attention by hook
          or  by CROOK, let us not fritter away our time rationaliz-
          ing the government action and the role of Indian media.

               The Sikhs  do  have  their  religious,  cultural  and
          linguistics rights protected in India like all other ethn-
          ical groups residing there. The government  of  India  has
          also  her  rights  to curb, if not exterminate, any seces-
          sionist movement to maintain her sovereignty. In the past,
          it  had  violently  combated to abet the secessionist fac-
          tions who operated under the pretext of political ideology
          or  the  regional  autonomy.  This time the 'sant' and his
          followers had maneuvered the secessionist  movement  under
          the fortification of their holy temple and thereby aroused
          the sentiment and passion of the  Sikh  community  by  and
          large.   The  right  minded  Sikhs who left the hearth and

                                                                   2

          haven at the West Punjab (which is  now  Pakistan)  during
          the  turmoil  of 1947 and migrated to India in a penurious
          condition  should  acknowledge  that  they  prospered  and
          entrenched their position at the different states of India
          by the cooperation of the Indian government and the  Indi-
          ans - Hindu, Muslim, Christian and others. This evanescent
          Sikh unrest is a parallax of their national spirit and may
          be, in the long perspective, MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING.


          Mazumder, Pinaki
          Coordinated Science Laboratory, U of I (U-C).
          ihnp4!uiucds!uicsld


=>
=>