[net.misc] Kramer on generating and testing solutions

rlr (08/09/82)

Given enough
time you would generate all solutions.  The set that you
do generate is generated at random, perhaps directly based on
QUANTUM events so that they cannot be predicted.  This makes the
behaviour of a person unpredictable (to an extent) no matter
how emmense your computing resources.
----------qouted from previous article

On the contrary, the method by which your brain generates solutions
(and the types of solutions it generates) is (are) fixed --- given
a situation and THE EXACT POSITION OF ALL OBJECTS IN THE VICINITY OF
THE PERSON THAT HAVE AN EFFECT ON THAT PERSON'S GENERATING A SOLUTION
(a truly unclear statement if there ever was one), I can determine
which solutions the person's brain will come up with and in what order
Note that the objects in question include the person him/herself---what
his/her eyes were directed at, what he/she was just thinking about, etc.,
all have an effect on the resulting decision.
And what does all this have to do with free will??  If unpredictable
"quantum events" occur in this universe, then the universe cannot be a
deterministic system.  But what it then becomes is a random system, not
one involving free will.  The randomness of these "quantum events" certainly
does not give an individual a system of choice any more than the deterministic
model.				Rich Rosen pyuxjj!rlr