[net.micro.mac] More Comments on MS-Word

iltis@ucsbcsl.UUCP ( ) (02/09/85)

First let me address some initial responses to my original posting about
MS-Word.

Disk Space:  The suggestion was made that I keep Word on a non-system disk
(i.e., put a disk containing the system file only in the internal (external)
drive and another disk containing Word and other applications in the second
drive.)  The problem with this technique is that it is inconvenient to put
data on the system disk and keep it organized.  I prefer to keep my applicaton
and system on one disk and all of my data on a second. If data and applications
have to share the same non-system disk, then I lose a lot of storage. The
solution is double-sided drives or a hard disk/new finder combination.

I would like to make some more criticisms relative to difficulties encountered
doing technical w.p. using MS-Word

Line Spacing:  The Princeton font for example allows one to build up large
brackets, integral signs, etc.  using different pieces of these symbols
 on multiple lines.  In the "auto" line-spacing mode it is possible to
form continuous vertical lines (useful for matrices) assuming that there
are no subscripts/superscripts on any of the lines.  However, subscripts
cause the vertical lines to separate leaving 1-2 pixel spaces between
them.  I tried using narrower line spacing using the paragraph format 
command.  Unfortunately, I found that the tops of the letters were now
cut off.  Unlike VM Macwrite in the 6 lines/inch mode, the tops of the
letters did not reappear when printed.

Subscripting and Superscripting:  Word automatically decreases the font size
of sub-superscripted text.  On the surface this seems like a good idea.
Unfortunately, many fonts such as Princeton and Omnisci are currently
being distributed in only 12 pt and 24 pt formats.  Thus writing in 12 pt
and using subscripts forces Word to interpolate to generate the 9 pt
subscripted font.  A better option would be to allow default settings
for subscript/superscript sizes.  i.e., assume that I select subscipts from
the menu while writing in 12 pt. font.  If I now go to the character format
menu and change the currently selected font size from 9 pt. back to 12 pt.,
all further subscripts should remain in 12 pt.  In the current version of
word, if the subscript font size is changed to 12 pt., upon returning
to plain text the font size is now increased to 14 pt.

Bug (feature?)  If a file is saved using Word, it is removed from
whatever folder it was originally in when returning to the desktop.
This happens with both save and save as.

General Performance of Word:  Word seems pretty fast opening, closing and
saving files.  Speed limitations are inherently due to the hardware
limitations of the Macintosh, mainly slow disk access.  The flashing
noted here and elsewhere on the current line seems very severe when
footnotes are used and when the current insertion point is moved back from
the diamond cursor position.  Scrolling through pictures seems much slower
on Word than in VM Macwrite.

Good points about Word: Word seems like a very solid program, I have not
lost a file yet which is what really counts on the Mac.  Also, unlike Apple,
Microsoft offers the "rest of us" TECHNICAL SUPPORT.  As a registered owner,
I am given a phone number to call about technical problems, and a bug report
sheet.  While working with IBM PC Microsoft products in the past, I have found
technical support to be quite good, Microsoft personnel to be quite courteous
(a real surprise in the computer industry) and very knowledgeable. 

From past experience, I feel that Microsoft treats me like a professional,
whereas Apple seems to believe that I need to be led by the hand. (anyone
see the cartoon about Apple in PC Week (Feb 4th))?

All opinions are my own and not necessarily those of my employer. 
-- 
Ronald A. Iltis
UCSB Dept. ECE