[net.misc] Freudian outrage

lew (09/02/82)

I think the reaction of outrage at Jo Jo's release shows a lot about
our own inner workings. After all, there must be a hundred worse
injustices perpetrated every day. Also, the reaction belies all of
our usual rationales for incarceration (rehabilitaion, protection of
society) and shows it to be irrationally motivated.

I believe this outrage is as Freudian as can be. Jo Jo represents
our own dark side. Deep down, we know ourselves to be capable of
atrocities such as Jo Jo actually committed. His release triggered
a fear that our own darker sides were threatening to break out.
Putting him back in prison made us feel secure again, but from
ourselves.  His gross obesity makes him the perfect symbol of the
id and is the key to the whole phenomenon.

	Lew Mammel, Jr. - BTL Indian Hill

dvk (09/03/82)

"...deep down, we know ourselves to be capable of atrocitites such as Jo Jo
actually committed". Well, Lew, I really don't know about that. I don't think
I could *EVER* commit a rape. (Have you ever been robbed? I think about how
invasive that is, and I get the willies...) Sure, mock rape is fun when both
parties involved are consenting, but real rape? No. Even other atrocities
like torturing small animals are too nasty for me. (There must be other
humanists in the world besides me.)

	-Dan Klein, Mellon Institute, Pittsburgh