[net.music.classical] re -- Pulitzer Prize for Music

parker@psuvax.UUCP (Bruce Parker) (05/01/84)

Perhaps I can shed some light on at least a few of the works:

1961	Symphony No. 7			Walter Piston

	I don't know the work, but the fellow is pretty conservative
	though still occasionally interesting.  His 6th is a buoyant work,
	recorded by Munch and the BSO on RCA.

1963	Piano Concerto No. 1		Samuel Barber

	I heard this in 1975 in Chautauqua, New York.  My memory
	doesn't serve me too well here, but I seem to recall that
	it was typical of his sterner conservative sensibilities.

1967	Quartet No. 3			Leon Kirchner

	It's available on a Vox Box set of avant garde American string
	quartets.  Unfortunately it's played by the Concord Quartet --
	a real bunch of bozos who have no sympathy or ability for
	classical or romantic repertoire, not that that matters much here
	except in terms of ensemble.  Buy it anyway -- at least
	they can play music I haven't heard elsewhere.  Still I wish
	the Juilliard would record this set.

1968	Echoes of Time and the River	George Crumb

	Great piece.  I heard and saw it (it is very much a theater piece)
	at Tanglewood in 1976.  There is a lousy recording of it
	by the Louisville Orchestra with pretty boy Jorge Mester conducting.

1972	Windows				Jacob Druckman

	One of my favorite composers.  Again I don't know this work
	but he has been composing in a progression of interesting styles
	for years.

1976	Air Music			Ned Rorem

	Again I don't know the work, but Rorem is rather conservative and dull.

1978	Deja Vu for Percussion Quartet	Michael Colgrass
	and orchestra

	There's a new recording out on New World records.  It's
	performed by Leonard Slatkin and the Saint Louis Symphony.
	The Colgrass is coupled with Druckman's impressionistic
	"Aureole".  I don't know "Deja Vu", but Michael Colgrass's
	"As Quiet as" is a carefully constructed, enjoyable work.

1980	In Memory of a Summer Day	David Del Tredici

	I've heard this and several others of his Alice series.
	Frankly I've grown tired of his poverty of invention.
	His skills seem misguided.  He should find another obsession,
	perhaps bricklaying.

1982	Concerto for Orchestra		Roger Sessions

	I read a favorable review of the piece in the Village Voice
	when it was premiered in Boston by Ozawa and the BSO.
	If you know Roger, nothing more be said.  If you don't, he's
	difficult to explain.  An inadequate comparison would be to
	say that he's a romantic Elliott Carter:  complex but not as
	harsh.  (This may also be confusing since Carter started out
	as a romantic.  So much for analogies.)  Why do I get
	this feeling that I read somewhere that it was recorded?