[net.music.classical] Mozart symphony recordings - which ones not to buy

greg@oliven.UUCP (Greg Paley) (02/20/85)

With the appearance of most of Bruno Walter's stereo recordings
on CD, I have no doubt that his late Mozart symphonies made in
stereo (late 50's or early 60's) with the Columbia Symphony
Orchestra will reappear, if they haven't already.  I can't
recommend these recordings, having listened to them in their
Columbia LP release.  

As Walter got older a tendency he always had to linger over
beautiful moments, sometimes to the point of bringing the music
to a grinding halt, got progressively worse.  I hear it in most
of his post World War II recordings, the exceptions being the
1952 Vienna "Das Lied von der Erde", the 1954 Mozart Requiem,
and the 1957 Mahler "Resurrection" symphony.  The Mozart
symphonies show this tendency at its worse.

Outstanding, however, if you can take very dated sound, are
the recordings of Mozart symphonies Walter recorded in the
late 30's.  In these, the beauty and expressiveness is maintained
within a coherent framework that doesn't impede the flow of the
music.  They are available on Japanese EMI pressings.

	- Greg Paley