[net.origins] Great Moments in Science Education

dubois@uwmacc.UUCP (Risky Rat) (07/31/85)

Ross H Arnett, Jr and Dale C Braungart, _An Introduction to Plant
Biology_ (third edition), C V Mosby, Saint Louis, 1970, pp311,313.

"Geologists have worked out a scale, the geological time scale, which
names the various periods of time since the beginning of the earth.
This scale is based primarily on the layers of stratified rock.
Volcanic rock is not dated in this manner because it cannot be measured
in time units.  It is possible to date both types of rock by
radioisotope studies.  The original time scales were dated by measuring
the thickness of each layer, and an estimate was then made of the
thickness of known silt deposits for a few years.  By careful
computations, and [sic] estimate of the time it took for a given
deposit to accumulate could be made.  After long study, the various
deposits were cooordinated and arranged into a time scale.  Actually,
the geologists used fossils to help date the rocks, and this practice
resulted in a paradox because the paleontologist used the rocks to date
his fossils!  However, when it became possible to date organic matter
by C-14 tests, the entire time scale was in need of only minor
adjustments."


Comment:  it is indeed distressing that carbon-14 is now only accurate
to at most 50,000 years, since in 1970 even Pre-Cambrian deposits
could be dated by that method.  Most unfortunate indeed! :-)

...One would think that by the third edition such an error would be
detected...

-- 
                                                                    |
Paul DuBois     {allegra,ihnp4,seismo}!uwvax!uwmacc!dubois        --+--
                                                                    |
"Why are you standing on one leg?"                                  |
"I'm trying to see if I'm a stork."