[net.origins] Comment

dubois@uwmacc.UUCP (Risky Rat) (08/08/85)

Dear Mr Holden,

I have been reading your postings with interest and enjoyment.  There
is, however, (at least) one aspect of your articles about which I find
myself somewhat disturbed.  This is that you seem to hold the sentiment
that you would like to see your adversaries ground into the earth.  I
can certainly understand your trepidation regarding the acceptance of
evolution, Darwinian or otherwise.  I cannot go along with the delight
that the ignominious defeat of the evolutionists would apparently give
you, as exemplified, e.g., in the following:

> I love this one!  The creatures Mr. Jefferys has in
> mind include several which I wouldn't  want to face
> with anything  less than  a 50 caliber machine gun.
> My favorite ancient animal  is  the  pteratorn...
>            ...In a way, it's a shame pteratorns are
> extinct.   I   really  feel  the  guys  at  the  UT
> astronomy department deserve a  shot  at  trying to
> kill one  with their  spears.  I am morally certain
> that the pteratorn would enjoy the meal as  much as
> I would  enjoy the  (brief) spectacle.

There is joy in a fight well fought, and often wisdom in the knowledge
gained thereby.  As to the outcome of the struggle, there is glory in
victory, and there may be dignity even in defeat.  But there are none
of these things in the desire to abjectly humiliate one's foes just to
be able to revel in their debasement.

-- 
                                                                    |
Paul DuBois     {allegra,ihnp4,seismo}!uwvax!uwmacc!dubois        --+--
                                                                    |
Ritual and Ceremony:  Life Itself.                                  |