[net.abortion] Machiavelli and abortion

peterr@utcsrgv.UUCP (Peter Rowley) (04/09/84)

In the interest of providing food for thought, I offer the beginnings of
a Machiavellian analysis of the issue of abortion.  Please, no flames--
I'm not saying that you, your friend, or anyone, acts this way; just
that it is conceivable that these considerations play a part in *some*
opinions.

Machiavelli claimed that everyone seeks to maximize their own power.  This
can be power to do whatever one wants to do, or power over what other people
do.  So he would claim that a pro-choice female solely wants the power to
control her own body.  And that any pro-life advocate wants to deprive
someone of the option of having an abortion solely to exert power over that
person.  I'm not sure what Machiavelli would say about a pro-choice male.

When considering the activities and statements of an organized group, it is
useful to wonder whether the members (or leader) of the group are truly
interested in the issue per se, or are primarily interested in increasing their
individual or collective power.

p. rowley, U. Toronto.