[net.religion.jewish] On forgetting and forgiving

mf@cornell.UUCP (mf) (05/02/85)

Lest we forget...  It is very easy to dismiss the strong reactions to
this president's visit to ``that'' cemetery.  After all, aren't they
dead, shouldn't our memories be dead too?  In the last few days, I have
spoken with many a survivor from the camps, as well as refugees and
people who had lived hidden, in fear, anguish and famine.  If they
were silent up to now, it is because of the excrutiating pain *they*
feel when remembering, and it is because of the silence imposed upon
them by those who don't want to hear and who don't want to know.

How can one forgive and forget in their name?  Theirs is a testimony
against a system which did not respect the elementary rights of everyone
to his own originality and particularity, not only about a fact of
dead history, but an evidence of an ever-present reality.

Their stories are ones of despair and hope, a very topical warning to
all of those who did not believe then and want to forget today, to
those who look at the serene and pastoral ruins of the camps sincerely
believing that they signify the death of a plague rather than the birth
of a new evil, and who pretend to believe that all this is of one time
and one country and who do not hear that people cry unceasingly.

If you don't know what I am talking about, find someone who lived this
season in hell, and listen.  Or watch. ``Night and Fog,'' say.  Here
are some personal sketches a friend and I heard.

Frederika, a very old woman, was telling me how the quotas prevented
her from entering the USA with her family, and how, consequently, she
had to go to Australia, while her mother and 3 sisters died in
Theresienstad.

Irmgard told me how she was imprisoned and tatooed (41-965) and later
made, along with other women, to stand in the courtyard of Auschwitz
and watch 3 women being hanged.  When she lowered her head so as not to
see, a German soldier hit her with the butt of his gun and told her
"You pig, you are supposed to watch."

As the Russians approached, she with other prisoners were packed like
cattle in open wagons and shipped for days without food and under snow
and rain to yet another concentration camp.

Upon her arrival here, she had to endure the guilt for having survived
and be a living testimony of the human-imposed barbarism, imposed by
her by complacent and well-fed people.  In spite of all, she is one
of the most wonderful, intelligent and gentle women I know.  And she
is still afraid, and she still has nightmares.

Mira couldn't tell me a thing, it is too painful for her, but her
friend told me some of the things that had happened to her: her husband
taken out of her house and shot in the street, her son (or nephew, I
don't recall) thrown live in the flames, her stay in one of the worst
camps, finally to be sent into the sea in boats without food or
steering means, and at every attempt at approaching the shore--to be
machine-gunned by the Nazis (they were rescued by the Russians).

A friend's mother was raped by a nazi soldier while she watched her
husband being shot.  Surviving that seems herculean...

Ernestine had her father taken out and shot (in Austria) because he was
Catholic and socialist.

I had a friend in Tucson.  He was hidden by a Christian lady in Belgium
for the duration.  One year, on Christmas eve, he decided to take the
chance to go out and buy her a Christmas present to thank her.  As he
approached the house after shopping, he saw the SS cars out front, so
slipped into a doorway and waited.  Apparently, the SS had been told
she was hiding a Jew;  when they came, she expressed shock that they
could even think such a thing, and invited them to search the premises
to confirm that no one else was there.  He was in hiding for something
like four years -- he only left the house that once for a couple
hours.  Such a narrow escape haunts him still.

Collective memory, collective pains.  If the only death that one knows
of is that of actors on a stage (who miraculously resurrect at the end
of the movie), of ridiculous Nazis in a sitcom, of Riefenstahl's
pageants, lack of empathy and sensitivity makes more ... sense.
Especially when political expediency is concerned.