[net.religion.jewish] Martillo and "who's Jewish"

rlr@pyuxd.UUCP (Rich Rosen) (09/06/85)

> In any case, Rosen got so upset a  year ago when I  said he was Jewish
> because his  mother was Jewish,  he should be  glad that I  have found
> legitimate reason to consider him a non-Jew. [MARTILLO]

Martillo's imagination is getting carried away with him again.  What you
said was not that I was Jewish because my mother is Jewish (which is a
very simple fact), but that because my mother was Jewish I was OBLIGED to
do certain things because HE says so.  Needless to say, this argument died
after repeated insistence by many people that this was just an assertion by
Martillo.

> Clearly he knows nothing about Judaism.   I suspect this ignorance was 
> handed down from his parents.

And what of your ignorance of Judaism, Yakky?  After all, you don't conform
to the obviously correct standards of us Ashkenazi slime types, thus it's
obvious that you don't qualify as Jewish.  What's that, Yakky, only your
opinion on this issue is the correct one?  What's the difference between your
assertions and mine above?

> Since the Jewish lineage of Ashkenazim is so dubious, I will take this
> tradition of ignorance among the Rosen family as prima facie evidence of
> non-Jewish   ancestry.  Therefore, Rosen   is probably  by ancestry a
> Christian.  (I  apologize to  Christians   on the  net  for "giving" them
> Rosen but the logic is inescapable.)

The foul disgusting bigotry evident in statements decrying the lineage of
certain groups of people and insisting that if you're not a "Jew" (by whose
standards?) you must be a "Christian", makes it clear what sort of person
we are dealing with.

> Rosen is so tolerant while I make some radical fundamentalist Christians sound
> almost human.   Well I know one group  which  used to identify some  group
> of people as  not human  as  Rosen has just done.  These people are the NAZIS.
> Sieg Heil, Rosen!

Pardon me, but did anyone see me declare a group of people as not human?
One thing we can be sure of:  people who bogusly refer to other people as
Nazis have learned a lot from the Nazis about fascistic manipulation.  One good
look at the "unbiased" objective way that Martillo looks at non-Sephardic
Jews tells us who is the bigot.

(For sure, this doesn't belong in net.religion.christian .)
-- 
"to be nobody but yourself in a world which is doing its best night and day
 to make you like everybody else means to fight the hardest battle any human
 being can fight and never stop fighting."  - e. e. cummings
	Rich Rosen	ihnp4!pyuxd!rlr