[net.consumers] MSG Allergies

rosen@exit26.DEC (Barry Rosen) (02/20/86)

I don't remember my chemistry that well so I'm not sure if sodium 
glutamate and monosodium glutamate are the same or if it makes any 
difference.  You will find sodium glutamate in many Japanese prepared 
foods particularly those made with the various types of seaweeds used 
in broths and soups.  Often, you don't know it's there because the 
seaweed is added for flavor but removed from the broth before serving. 
Kombu is generally used this way.  Miso soup based products are an
example which derive most of their flavor this way.  You will also
find a great deal of salt in many of the products.  Again, the 
seaweeds are one of the sources.  [There are many others.]  Many of 
this products which are sold in packaged form in this country will 
carry a label telling the consumer to cold water rinse and scrub the 
product to remove about 40% of the salts.  Because the products are 
used in Japan, do not assume that they are without risk nor that they 
are the equivalent product.

While it may be true that less than 10% of the U.S. population may be 
allergic to MSG, anything approaching this number is a lot of people.  
The general population of the U.S. is MORE allergic to more things 
than most other countries of the world.  [There are numerous 
references to site here but they all boil down to a growing number of 
MD's in the world who call their particular study and treatment of 
allergies clinical ecology.]  They feel that we are (as a population) 
still becoming allergic to more things.  MSG is one of the chemicals 
to which we become allergic and which "helps" us to become more 
sensitized to the things around us.

How valid is all this?  I now believe very valid based on the 
discussions I have had with allergic people and with the amount of 
reading I have been doing on this topic recently.  My conservative 
approach is to avoid things which can add more stress to the body so I 
avoid MSG.