[net.puzzle] Barge Problem - The Answer

johnf@apollo.uucp (John Francis) (12/05/85)

When the iron is taken out of the barge,  the barge rises out of the water
so that the mass of water displaced is decreased by an amount equal to the
mass of the iron. This lowers the water level in the lock, since the total
volume below the water level is now less. Is the barge now higher or lower
with respect to the lock?  Answer :  It must already be higher.  If it was
at the same level then the water level would be the same as before, and so
the barge would NOT have risen with respect to the water. If the barge was
lower (WRT the lock) than before then more of the barge would be below the
original water level, and thus the extra water displaced would have caused
the water level in the lock to rise.

So even before we throw the iron into the lock the barge has risen.  After
throwing the iron into the lock the barge rises even more!