kiessig@idi.UUCP (Rick Kiessig) (01/02/84)
[Some of you may get this before an article from agkua!glc. I am sending this in response to Lindsay's message]. I can see your concern over the information that I'm asking for. Let me point out a few things: 1. Everything posted to Usenet is public domain. This includes article content as well as return addresses. 2. Everything in public telephone books is public domain. 3. No personal contact information is being published without an individual's OK. 4. You can garner a lot more about someone by reading their netnews articles than you can from a single line in a directory. 5. A headhunter will get more useful information from the Usenix attendees list and your secretary than from the directory. Besides, if you're going to be solicited, wouldn't you rather get a mail message than a phone call? 6. If you're paranoid about "Big Brother", you don't have to be listed (yes, I will accept specific requests to be left out of the directory). However, in that case I would recommend you also not be listed in your company phone book (you would be suprised how many headhunters already have copies) or your local public phone book. And don't subscribe to anything by US mail, or your name will be sold to a half-dozen or more mail-order houses. Don't send anything to any news group, don't go to any professional conferences. Etc. 7. I don't know why you haven't found me in net.news.newsite. I came on-line and posted an article there several weeks ago. Mark Horton at cbosgd keeps copies, or I can mail you one if you want to see it. 8. I will be happy to provide you with a dial-in when I get one. They only ran two phone lines into my building, and I use one for voice and one for both voice and data. I have to dig a ditch from the phone drop before they can install a third line - the phone company won't do it for me. 9. It is true that my machine is new. However, I've been involved in the UNIX and uucp communities almost since they came out of the Labs. In fact, it is this long involvment from which my frustration stems about not having a UUCP Directory. -- Rick Kiessig {decvax, ihnp4, cbosgd, ucbvax}!sun!idi!kiessig
rjk@mgweed.UUCP (Randy King) (01/06/84)
I see both Linday's point of view as well as Rick's. The most important facet of trust *anywhere* is communication. And like any relationship, when that breaks down (sites dropping certain information) trust tends to fade. This mistrust is enhanced by the current state of information- seeking entities. That's what it's all about, no? Gathering, sorting and disseminating information. I see what Rick is doing. Worst case (*I* don't feel this way) he will *sell* the list to some group of headhunters who will call you. However, that is a hell of a lot of work, and they wouldn't pay him for what his time is worth to compile this information. Beleive me, he is *exactly correct* about "calling the secretary" or getting a company directory. One day the phones in our department rang almost sequentially from the same headhunter! My wife has had the same experience. I tend to believe that what Rick is doing is somehow going to benefit us more than hurt us; the community of tech-pros. Personally, as far as headhunters are concerned, I like to have that ace in my pocket "just in case". My resume tends to be up-to-date by the week, and if I ever feel that my career is being stifled, I'm outta here, so to speak, and the knowlege of where to start looking, and the fact that someone *might* have heard of me is comforting. Think about it... Randy King mgweed!rjk