[net.legal] A Legal Paradox

mikeb@ptsfa.UUCP (Michael Barkley) (05/15/85)

		    MA BELL AND THE SEVEN LITTLE BELLS
				A FABLE


	Once upon a time there was a naughty lady named Ma Bell.  In fact this
lady was SO naughty, she had to go to Court.  She spent many years in Court,
and the longer she was there the worse it got.  They actually wanted to draw
and quarter her.  So at the last possible moment she worked out a plea bargain:
she would lose some weight (which she wanted to do anyway), she wouldn't be
able to do newspapers for seven years, and she would be permitted to do many
new and interesting things she wasn't allowed to do before, and we all know
this is much better than being drawn and quartered, right?  

	Well, the Judge knew that as part of the plea bargain Ma would soon
be giving birth to seven little Baby Bells.  The Judge was very worried that
the seven Baby Bells some day might possibly maybe conceivably perhaps could
do some of the naughty things that Ma once was alleged to have done, so the
Judge ordered that when and if the Baby Bells were born they would be locked
up absolutely forever, or until they became so decrepit they could no longer
walk unassisted (which he may or may not allow depending on whether or not
they could prove that there was absolutely positively no chance whatsoever
of any of Ma's alleged naughty behavior recurring, not ever, no way)
whichever came first.

	So while Ma was doing her time the seven Baby Bells were born, and
everyone was impressed with what wonderfully healthy Baby Bells they were.
After a few months these bouncing Baby Bells began to Think Independently 
(which, after all, was what they had been told to do) and looked around and
wondered why they were locked up while the entire rest of the world was
having a good time Thinking Independently without being locked up.  So the
Baby Bells went to the Judge and asked if they could do their Thinking
Independently out in the real world along with everyone else.  Well, needless
to say, the Judge was furious!  He said why didn't you tell me before you
were born that you would be wanting to do this?  He said didn't I do enough
for you by providing that if you ever got so decrepit you could not walk
unassisted you could walk back to me and ask to be released (which I may or
may not allow depending on whether or not you could prove that there was 
absolutely positively no chance whatsoever of any of Ma's alleged naughty
behavior recurring, not ever, no way)?  He said that just to show he was a
nice guy he would allow a little freedom.  He said that you could designate
any 10% of your Baby Bell bodies as eligible for freedom, he would make a
hole in the fence just big enough to stick that 10% out through so you could
wave it around in the free air outside the fence, but first you had to have
surgery to make absolutely sure there would be no blood or nerve impulses
moving back and forth between these small pieces parts and the main Baby
Bell, and isn't that generous of me?

	Well, the Baby Bells pondered this, and decided to accept the
wonderful generosity of the kindly Judge, and had the surgery performed.
But they still wondered exactly what it was they had done before they
were born that caused them to be treated like second class citizens....

	The moral of this tale is, if your neighbor's kids are bothering you,
or you think they will have kids someday who might bother you, have the
neighbors prosecuted for alleged antitrust violations and you'll never
have to worry about their kids again....

			- - - - - - - -

	Some anonymous person has suggested to me anonymously that I add a
disclaimer to this little fable, so here goes:  These words are not my
employer's words; These words are not even my words; I believe God spoke
these words to me in the middle of the night, but he wouldn't leave his
name, so I guess this is a cosmic anonymous letter....

				--mikeb, 415/261-7189