[net.legal] Don Black, the Holocaust, and the Ontario legal system

dave@lsuc.UUCP (David Sherman) (09/20/85)

Don Black also had the following wonderful comment about the Zundel trial:

> Message-ID: <3304@decwrl.UUCP>
>      As for Hitler not killing any Jews, well, I guess there are pro's and
> con's of the subject, aren't there?  I suppose the subject has been "proven" 
> in a courtroom.  But that's relatively easy to do when the jury's been 
> brainwashed, and the judge has been paid off.

Quite aside from my reaction to this as a Jew, as a member of
the Law Society of Upper Canada I am outraged at this statement.
The Canadian criminal justice system as administered in Ontario
is as fair and impartial as any in the world. The Ontario
judiciary are honourable and reputable men and women. Alleging
that the judge (Judge Hugh Locke of Ontario District Court) has
been "paid off" is a vile libel against Judge Locke and against
the Ontario legal system. Mr. Black should retract this claim
unless he can back it up.

As to the jury being "brainwashed", both the Crown and the defense
had ample opportunity to present their cases to the jury. The jury
concluded unanimously beyond a reasonable doubt that the Holocaust
happened and that Zundel was lying. Doesn't that speak for itself?

(Comments that Mr. Black didn't actually *say* that the judge was
paid off, only that "that's relatively easy to do when...", may be
directed to /dev/null. His point was quite clear and his language
quite explicit. Comments to the effect that he didn't refer to the
Zundel case by name may also be directed to /dev/null.)

David Sherman
The Law Society of Upper Canada
Toronto
-- 
{  ihnp4!utzoo  pesnta  utcs  hcr  decvax!utcsri  }  !lsuc!dave