willson.uci%Rand-Relay@sri-unix.UUCP (06/24/83)
From: Stephen Willson <willson.uci@Rand-Relay> ------- Forwarded Message Date: 23 Jun 1983 10:55:54-EDT From: csin!cjh@CCA-UNIX Received: from cca-unix by rand-relay.ARPA ; 23 Jun 83 07:57:08 PDT (Thu) Subject: re Jedi is garbage To: willson.uci@rand-relay Cc: sf-lovers@rutgers Via: Rand-Relay; 23 Jun 83 18:04-PST Your other hope is SPEILBERG?!?!? The man has no story sense \\and// none of the feeling for when an effect will work that Lucas has (can you name any scene in any of Speilberg's work that carries the immediate impact of the opening shot in SW IV? (Don't talk to me about "Closet Cases of the Nerd Kind"; the mother ship is just an oversized and unbelievable Xmas tree ornament which we never see in a way that gives it scale.) ------- End of Forwarded Message When I sent my message to sf-lovers, I sent it to "sf-lovers" instead of "uci-sf-lovers". Oops. So this guy, whereever he is, replied. I guess this means that sf-lovers is alive out there and we're just not getting it.