[net.comics] Brood vs. Wraiths

dub@pur-phy.UUCP (Dwight U. Bartholomew) (08/24/84)

(from: Paul Simmington)

To all readers:
	I wish to bring out an apparent contraversy between myself
and a compatriot.  It entails the use of the Wraiths as the only
danger to Earth.  There have been many foes to fall from the heavens
to attempt to take over Earth.
	My concern is between the Brood and the Sisterhood.  In my
opinion, it appears that the Brood was more threatening than the
Wraiths could ever be.
	I base this on five points:
1) Higher intelligence
2) Superior technology
3) Less violence
4) Character development
	THe Brood has obviously higher technology; having
(living) craft with the capability of "warp" drive.  Also their
weapons are far more developed than magical chants.
	Secondly, to have "warp" drive, they had to be able to
adapt alien technology.  Their aggresive nature also helped in
developing and refining their environment and demonstrates their
intelligence.
	Another vital point is that the Brood, when shown,
was not really violent.  Of course, there are scenes that show
their barbaric nature, but they are less violent than one
episode of Rom.
	The brood have the ability to return, making Earth
and the X-men pay for their previous defeat.
	The fourth point which distinguishes the Brood as
more superior is the character development that takes place all
around them.  An example is Storm's role.  She was taken out into
space and feared that the "Goddess" had forsaken her.  That
began the steps towards the new Storm.
	Colossus was different; he realized that he was dumb.
The self-doubt began to plague him (as in a later time, when
he was battling the Juggernaut and got no aid from Wolverine
or Nightcrawler.)
	Wolverine showed development, for he was willing to
kill the X-men rather than see them become a part of the Brood.
	The final point is that the Brood had limited enemies.
Basically they had the X-men (espacially after Colossus was hurt.)
The Starjammers entered the scenes later, but then left for the
open skies and the vacuum of space (and the Sh'iar empire.)
(Of course, the Brood's most effective enemy is Binary (Carol
Danvers, whose powers rival a "herald's".)
	Well, I have explained the five different points
that separate the Brood fromthe Wraiths.  I would be interested
in other reader's points of view.  Send flames...I love'em.

			Paul Simmington
			Northwestern University

<the views expressed in this article>
<are not necessarily those of dub.  >
<..snicker.....                     >

moriarty@fluke.UUCP (Jeff Meyer) (08/28/84)

Actually, I think the modern trend is that ANY alien who does something
gross to you (suck your brains out, lay eggs in your liver, etc.) is a major
threat.  Makes you miss the Kree;  all they did was land soldiers with ray
guns, and maybe take the freshest meat at the local Safeway.

		"Let's show this prehistoric bitch how we do things downtown!"

					Moriarty, aka Jeff Meyer
					John Fluke Mfg. Co., Inc.
UUCP:
 {cornell,decvax,ihnp4,sdcsvax,tektronix,utcsrgv}!uw-beaver \
    {allegra,gatech!sb1,hplabs!lbl-csam,decwrl!sun,ssc-vax} -- !fluke!moriarty
ARPA:
	fluke!moriarty@uw-beaver.ARPA