[net.comics] Recent Reviews

hsut@pur-ee.UUCP (Yuk Hsu) (08/15/85)

	Looks like things got straightened out here at Purdue Usenet-wise
(thanks, Phil!) so here again are a few books no one else reviewed yet...



MOONSHADOW #4

	Rah! Recognition at last for one of my favourites: the letters
column contains excerpts of letters from Ray Bradbury and Kurt Vonnegut.
Certainly didn't expect Vonnegut to admit he reads comics (he didn't use
to admit he wrote science fiction either.) While I feel the series
has been on a slight decline since the first two excellent issues
(still marvelously entertaining tho; no pun intended), the end of this one
hints of a welcome change of scene from the Machovia storyline. 
A few scenes stand out in this one: Moonshadow's confrontation with war,
and the "Icarus" sequence, for instance. Ira was a little out of character
this time, but maybe he was meant to be more complex than what I expected.


TIMESPIRITS #6

	Tom Yeates' art just gets better with each issue. Some of the
panels are close to sublime (cover and some of the Hendrix scenes.)
Not one of Steve Perry's better issues though; the script tends to be a
little heavy-handed in its polemics. Character development is,
as usual for this book, economical and well-done.


CEREBUS #75

	Yeah, yeah, I know somebody else has reviewed this one. But I can't
resist putting in my own two bits about what a great book this is,
and how well Dave Sim handles the subtle little things that go on when
his characters interact. Cerebus is one of the most human (!) characters
in comics these days. Has anyone on the net met Dave Sim? Is he really a
jerk or is he just pretending to be one? How can a jerk write and draw
such a beautiful, sensitive book?


					Bill Hsu
					pur-ee!hsut

ciaraldi@rochester.UUCP (Mike Ciaraldi) (08/20/85)

> Has anyone on the net met Dave Sim? Is he really a
> jerk or is he just pretending to be one? How can a jerk write and draw
> such a beautiful, sensitive book?
> 
> 
> 					Bill Hsu
> 					pur-ee!hsut

Well, I met Dave Sim back in 1980 (long-time net readers
have heard this story before).
He was a guest at the first Creation Con in Rochester, November 1980,
along with Mark Gruenwald and Keith Pollard.

At that point Cerebus #21 had just come out, and the print run
had recently been doubled from 6000 to 12,000. So, Cerebus
was still something of a cult comic (which it still is, come to
think of it, it's just that the cult is a little bigger).

Since no one knew who Sim was, I got to talk to him for much of
an afternoon.  He seemed just a fairly nice person, somewhat weird
(like most of the intelligent people I meet), but very committed to
his work.  He also had a keen sense of humor.

On the other hand, he was interviewed one afternoon on stage in front of about
25 people who happened to show up (compared to capacity crowds for
Gruenwald and Pollard), and seemed in a much worse mood.
He was rather surly and didn't follow up on the interviewer's
questions, so he had to be drawn out.

Years later, he wrote about that weekend in one of the 
"Swords of Cerebus" volumes (#3, I think), and basically said he
had been in a bad mood all weekend, compounded by being alone 
in a strange city with no downtown nightlife.

So, (putting on amateur psychologist cap), I think the reasons
Dave Sim comes off so nasty sometimes (especially in the letter columns)
are  that he does have a streak of it which comes out when he
is tired or overworked or bored (which probably happens quite often,
considering he has to run a publishing company and write and draw
20 pages of comics every month), plus his own sense of mischief and irony
which makes him want to play up his reputation.  I think you can see both 
sides of his personality alternating in the letter columns.

So, Dave, if you're reading this, we still love you even if
Jaka did get married to someone else.

Mike Ciaraldi
seismo!rochester!ciaraldi

peter@baylor.UUCP (Peter da Silva) (08/21/85)

> Has anyone on the net met Dave Sim? Is he really a
> jerk or is he just pretending to be one? How can a jerk write and draw
> such a beautiful, sensitive book?
> 
> 
> 					Bill Hsu
> 					pur-ee!hsut

Dave Sim isn't a jerk, just a guy who gets VERY grumpy when he's tired. Any
body can suffer from this... I recently had a run-in with Wendy Pini near the
end of a con which was most enlightning, though I hear she's generally pretty
good towards rabid fen.
-- 
	Peter (Made in Australia) da Silva
		UUCP: ...!shell!neuro1!{hyd-ptd,baylor,datafac}!peter
		MCI: PDASILVA; CIS: 70216,1076