[net.religion] Galileo & Biblical authority

lew (03/10/83)

Galileo had a fascinating way of subverting ecclesiastical authority
by turning church doctrine back on itself, practicing a sort of
rhetorical jiu-jitsu. For example, in his "Letter to the Grand Duchess
Christina", he asserts that since the bible is infallible, it obviously
cannot contradict the evidence of our senses, so that any apparent
contradictions must be due to faulty interpretations.

In his "Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems", Salviati
(his fictional mouthpiece) responds to the citation of physical evidence
in support of biblical correctness by saying, "Oh, that is worst of all,
for he is pretending to have things which are more effective and convincing
than the authority of Holy Writ. But let us, for our part, revere it, and
pass on to physical and human arguments." (Creationists take note.)

I take this to mean that since the bible is perfect and unchallengeable,
nothing more need be said about it, so we will just ignore it.

	Lew Mammel, Jr. ihuxr!lew