[net.religion] Bye, bye atheists in foxholes--you just cut your own throat

morganr@csu-cs.UUCP (05/25/83)

Well, well, well... thekid has fallen into the clutches of my latest
research in our cult library... namely, the phenomena of abreactive
shock.

William Sargent, in his book 'The mind posessed', has observed many facets
of this occourence.  A.S. is essentialy an emotional breakdown, brought
about by *any* strenuous situation.  For a period of time afterwards,
the mind is highly suggestible.  This was originally observed by Pavlov,
who noted that when his dog pens were flooded, bringing much strain to
the dogs, many of them were 'wiped clean' of conditioning.

The first place he observed it (take note, thekid), was in battlefield
situations!  Abreactive shock occoured spontaneously, alowing release of
emotional tension (remember this), and discharge of pent-up neuroses.
Soldiers that continued to be placed in stress would often have to have
this abreactive shock brought on by drugs or by hypnosis.  An extension
of this is the now much abused shock treatment.

After the war (WWII), the author began doing research with African tribes,
and observed *the same phenomena* in their religous worship, prayers, and
trances!  This should offend no-one, since we're certainly not Africans.

The real kicker, however, is that upon his return to the states, he managed
to observe this in the great majority of rapid conversions! To anything,
including Christianity!  His thesis, which he supports quite well, is that
the emotional tension built up by singing, fiery preaching, etc. was sufficient
to produce a mild abreative shock, and the subsequent suggestability.
What he also observed, was that this suggestability was not limited to
religion, but included highly promiscuous sexual activity.

I wouldn't reccomend that anyone read the whole thing, unless you really
enjoy detailed case studies of obscure african tribes, but the introduction
and his observations on fundamentalist Christians are fascinating.

I propose that there are two types of 'conversions'.  One is the 'path
of least resistance' conversion, where one desires to please one's family,
friends, etc.  The other, quite obviously, involves abreactive shock.  In
reading Mike Warnke's book 'The Satan Seller', I discovered that it
read like Sargent's case studies.  Both Mike's conversion to Satanism
and later to Christianity occoured in highly stressful circumstances.

So, thekid, your 'Athiests in foxholes' statement does nothing but support
the psychological explanation for rapid conversion.  No miracles, no
divine intervention, just the human mind protecting itself from stress.

There and Back Again,
Karl of Godelbach
Stonehaven, Outlands, Atenvelt, SCA
Fort Collins, Colorado
hao!csu-cs!morganr