[net.religion] A ton of replies

starner@ih4ep.UUCP (05/26/83)

Relay-Version:version B 2.10 5/3/83; site mhuxt.UUCP
Posting-Version:version B 2.10 5/16/83; site ih4ep.UUCP
Message-ID:<156@ih4ep.UUCP>
Date:Wed, 25-May-83 20:40:55 EDT
Organization:BTL Naperville, Il.


	"If God is omnipotent, His behavioral repertoire includes
	 all possible events, but if He has an attribute then
	 there are events which are not in his repertoire."

To say that a creature X (i.e. God) has an attribute A means
no more than that when given a choice X will act according to A.
However, it is still possible for X to not act according to A.
Thus having A in no way limits X's omnipotence. Omnipotence seems
merely to require that the omnipotent being **be able** to do
anything he/she/it chooses.

Example of having an attribute:  John Doe is a non-smoker.  In fact,
John never smokes his entire life.  Nevertheless, at any time
John could have chosen to smoke.
--

				Guy Starner
				ihnp4!ih4ep!starner
				Bell Laboratories