[net.religion] Romulus as proto-Christ

lew@ihuxr.UUCP (Lew Mammel, Jr.) (04/05/84)

This is from Livy's EARLY HISTORY OF ROME:

	[Of Romulus] In his view the rabble over whom he ruled could be
	induced to respect the law only if he himself adopted certain
	visible signs of power; he proceeded, therefore, to increase the
	dignity and impressiveness of his position by various devices, of
	which the most important was the creation of the twelve lictors
	to attend his person.  Some have fancied that he made the lictors
	twelve in number because the vultures, in the augury, had been twelve;
	personally, however, I incline to follow the opinion which finds for
	this an Etruscan origin.

The death of Romulus:

	Such, then, were the deeds of Romulus, and they will never grow
	old. One day while he was reviewing his troops on the Campus Martius
	near the marsh of capra, a storm burst, with violent thunder. A
	cloud enveloped him, so thick that it hid him from the eyes of
	everyone present; and from that moment he was never seen again upon
	earth.

	The troops, who had been alarmed by the sudden storm, soon recovered
	when it passed over and the sun came out again. Then they saw that
	the throne was empty, and, ready though they were to believe the
	senators, who had been standing at the king's side and now declared
	that he had been carried up on high by a whirlwind, they none the
	less felt like children bereft of a father and for a long time stood
	in sorrowful silence. Then a few voices began to proclaim Romulus's
	divinity; the cry was taken up, and at last every man present hailed
	him as a god and son of a god, and prayed to him to be for ever
	gracious and to protect his children. However, even on this great
	occasion there were, I believe, a few dissentients who secretly
	maintained that the king had been torn to pieces by the senators.
	At all events the story got about, though in veiled terms; but it
	was, moreover, given further credit by the timely action of a certain
	Julius Proculus, a man we are told, honoured for his wise counsel
	on weighty matters. The loss of the king had left the people in an
	uneasy mood and suspicious of the senators, and Proculus, aware of
	the prevalent temper, conceived the shrewd idea of addressing the
	Assembly. 'Romulus,' he declared, 'the father of our City, descended
	from heaven at dawn this morning and appeared to me. In awe and
	reverence I stood before him, praying for permission to look upon his
	face without sin. "Go," he said, "and tell the Romans that by
	heaven's will my Rome shall be capital of the world. Let them learn
	to be soldiers. Let them know, and teach their children, that no
	power on earth can stand against Roman arms." Having spoken these
	words, he was taken up again into the sky.'

This was written around 29 BC, giving it comfortable precedence over
the Gospels. The described events were c. 750 BC. I find the parallels
quite suggestive, and they are bolstered by the significance that Rome
had in the minds of the founders of Christianity as the ultimate wordly
power.  I would imagine "The City of God" was meant to stand in contra-
distinction to Rome. It's a wonder that this was overlooked by Graham
with his list of avatars.

Compare the following statements of Elaine Pagels in THE GNOSTIC GOSPELS
with Livy's description of Proculus's speech:

	Whatever we think of the historicity of the orthodox account,
	we can admire its ingenuity. For this theory - that all authority
	derives form certain apostles' experience of the resurrected
	Christ, an experience now closed forever - bears enormous
	implications for the political structure of the community. First,
	as the German scholar Karl Holl has pointed out, it restricts
	the circle of leadership to a small band of persons whose members
	stand in a position of incontestable authority.  Second, it
	suggests that only the apostles had the right to ordain future
	leaders as their successors.

Here we have sort of an Anthropic Principle of the Resurrection: the
events had to occur as they did to establish the Church.

Oh well, a friend of mine read all this stuff and told it to me :-)

	Lew Mammel, Jr. ihnp4!ihuxr!lew