[net.religion] Craig Stanfill talks about The Damager God

pez@pyuxn.UUCP (Paul Zimmerman) (10/17/85)

Craig,

	You claim that my opinions on God as evil suffer from illogic. You
assert (wrongly) that I seem to implicitly change my stance on whether God
created the universe or not. More than just generally saying that He did not,
I have offered a logical proof by contradiction that He did not. However,
he does tamper with the universe that does exist that He is a part of,
corrupting the natural flow of things. In any case, even if He did create
us, you claim that because ``we are His,'' He has the right to do with us
whatever He wants. Obviously He has deceived you very well into believing
that you ``belong'' to Him and owe Him something. You don't.

	Further, you say ``if God did not create the world, why assume that
God also bears responsibility for disease and natural disaster?'' I fail to
see how one follows the other. We did not create the world, yet you claim
we are responsible for the evil in it. God IS very powerful (though certainly
not omnipotent), and with or without creating the world He is still certainly
capable of the damage I attribute to Him. You finally claim that I ``do not
have [your] God, the God of Abraham, but someone else's God, a monotheistic
version of Zeus.'' Forgive me, but how do you know that ``your God'' is
not a monotheistic version of Zeus lying to you through His teeth? The
evidence seems to support that very notion.

Be well,
-- 
Paul Zimmerman - AT&T Bell Laboratories
pyuxn!pez