[net.women] Correlation: mode of dress vs. perceived ability

heretyk@abnjh.UUCP (S. Heretyk) (02/08/84)

Betty Lehan Harragan has an interesting chapter on dress
in "Games Mother Never Taught You".
Basically don't dress sexy, buy shoes you can walk in (foot
crippling shoes have been a favorite method to keep women
in their place), buy clothes with pockets (get rid of your
pocketbook), and save your perfume for night when it can
perform its function of making you a desirable sex object.
Sometimes it's hard to find a blouse that you can't see through - how can
women be respected if they walk around showing off their underwear?
Also high collar blouses are in style which look nice
under a jacket as opposed to open collars.
Also it makes a replacement for a tie - as do necklaces (not
funky ones).  On women wearing ties Betty Harrigan states
"Never wear a man's tie. Never, never, never.  A man's
tie is a penis symbol.  No woman with any self-respect
wants to walk around advertising 'I'm pretending I have a penis'"

Shelley Heretyk

ecs@inuxd.UUCP (Eileen Schwab) (02/09/84)

Red Sonja (?) has reported an inverted U relationship between
dress and perceived competence.  I have noted the beginning of 
this curve, but not the end (probably because I don't go 'all 
out' in dressing).  

When I first began teaching (large intro psych courses),
I would wear pressed slacks, shirts, and a jacket or vest.  When I
received my evaluations, most of the complaints concerned my appearance
(Some concerned my NYC accent, and a few concerned teaching 
effectiveness).  The students complained about my lack of makeup, nail
polish, and styled (curled) hair.  They objected to the fact that I 
wore pants rather than dresses.  They complained about my socks <I 
would have sworn I never wore the electric pink ones! |-)> and shoes.
I was shocked and infuriated.  

Nevertheless, I changed my appearance.  I began to wear suits, 
heels, and a bun.  Upon checking around, I learned that several 
female professors had similar evaluation experiences.  
NOT ONE male professor did.  This included males who wore well-broken-in
blue jeans while teaching. It still makes me mad.

     /\ 
   /V  V\                Eileen Schwab
  / ^  ^ \
  \______/          "Some like it HOT!"
    

aeq@pucc-h (Jeff Sargent) (02/14/84)

A friend of mine works as a "consultant" for the Computing Center here.  (A
"consultant" in this case is one who sits in a little office at one of our
sites and answers questions from users who need assistance using the
computers.)  Alternatively, here is her definition of "consultant":

consultant n. [From con "to defraud, dupe, swindle," or, possibly,
  French con (vulgar) "a person of little merit" + sult elliptical form
  of "insult."]  A tipster disguised as an oracle, especially one who
  has learned to decamp at high speed in spite of the large briefcase
  and heavy wallet.

Anyway, she sent me the following and asked me to post it to net.women
for her (since consultants are not yet allowed to post to the net):

--- Begin article

I have noticed an inverted u relationship for the amount of goodies (i.e. 
cosmetics, drees) I have and the way the users relate to me ( relate used to
be a perfectly good word before the 'pop' psychologists got ahold of it).
When I am dressed and 'made-up' as I am today (no make-up, jeans and shirt),
the users seem to think I'm just another user, and not, as we say in the 
business ' an authority figure'.  When I put on a bit of the Clinque (trdmk
Estee Lauder....I'm not planning on wrinkling thank you) and got up a notch
on clothes (cords, reasonable sweaters, that sort of thing), all of a sudden
they recognize me as 'the consultant'.  However, (especially if I'm team
consulting) if I take it one step further, then most of the users think
I am 'the consultant's girlfriend' and won't approach me.  There appears to be
a constant relationship between make-up and perceived ability at the computer
to a certain point, which then becomes a negative relationship ( as make-up
amounts go up, perceived ability goes down).  I haven't seen a similar 
relationship between the male consultants, and lets say, mode of dress....


There's a paper in here somewhere....

--- End article

Any responses may be posted to net.women (anyone here can READ news) or
mailed to (I think this works):

Red Sonja
...pur-ee!pucc-k:afo