rcd@opus.UUCP (Dick Dunn) (03/18/85)
Well, as promised a while back, here's an edited summary of the responses to the query I put out a while back. Comments from many people indicated that they had a good idea of what I was talking about, and helped me define the genre better--though I still lack a good name for it. I did eliminate two sorts of responses (when I recognized them)--songs which are merely long without a progression of theme/style/etc., and concept albums. I'm not knocking either of these; they just don't fit the category. Of course, somehow there's a progression of style from a longer piece with a progression of themes through a seamless set of separate songs to a concept album. See Rich Rosen's article <677@pyuxd> for more discussion of classifying various longer pieces. I also filtered out some of the non-rock. There are probably some bad calls here. (Yah, I know--what the hell IS rock, anyway?) I tried to zap only broad categories and not split hairs. OK--first the list by artist and title. There are a bunch I HAVE NOT heard (and some artists I've never even heard of before), so don't quarrel with me about the things that are here--if I didn't recognize it, I included it. After the list there's a little more discussion. Many thanks to the 40 or so people who contributed! -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Alan Parsons Project Fall of the House of Usher Allman Brothers Whipping Post Mountain Jam In Memory of Elizabeth Reed You Don't Love Me Amon Duul 2 Tanz der Lemminge Anderson, Jon Olias of Sunhillow (+Vangelis) Horizons Ashra Tempel Join Inn Beatles A Day in the Life Golden Slumbers Medley (Abbey Road Side II) Butterfield Blues Band East-West Camel The Snow Goose Canned Heat Refried Boogie Fried Hockey Boogie Chambers Brothers Time Crass Yes Sir, I Will Cream Spoonful (actually, this song invites a lot of work from any decent band) Crosby, Stills, Nash Suite: Judy Blue Eyes Dire Straits Telegraph Road Tunnel of Love Doors The End When the Music's Over The Soft Machine Earth, Wind, and Fire Zanzibar Electric Light Orch. Concerto for a Rainy Day Emerson, Lake, Palmer Karn Evil 9 Froese Epsilon in Malaysian Pale Genesis Supper's Ready Lamb Lies Down on Broadway (more nearly concept) Grateful Dead Terrapin Station Dark Star St. Stephen The Other One Weather Report Suite (Let it Grow) Grobschnitt Rockpommel's Land Hillage, Steve Fish Rising Iron Butterfly In-a-Gadda-da-Vida James Gang Bomber Medley Jethro Tull Thick as a Brick Passion Play John, Elton Funeral for a Friend/Love Lies Bleeding FM Head Room Border Crossing Kansas Magnum Opus King Crimson The Court of the Crimson King Led Zeppelin Stairway to Heaven Mandalaband Eye of Wendor Mayall, John Room to Move McLean, Don American Pie Moody Blues Nights in White Satin The Question Mountain Nantucket Sleighride Nektar Remember the Future Phillips, Anthony 1984 Pink Floyd Echoes Shine on You Crazy Diamond Dogs Procol Harum In Held 'Twas In I Pulsar Strands of the Future Rare Earth Get Ready Renaissance Scheherazade (? - this was spelled so many ways that I can't spell it right any more!:-) Mother Russia Rundgren, Todd; Utopia The Ikon Rush 2112 Cygnus X-1 Xanadu Hemispheres Rutherford, Mike Smallcreep's Day Soviet France Mohnomishe Stewart, Al Nostradamus Roads to Moscow Super Session Season of the Witch Throbbing Gristle 2nd Annual Report Traffic Glad Low Spark of High-Heeled Boys Dream Gerrard Ultimate Spinach Jazz Thing War City, Country, City Who Overture/Underture Quadrophenia (?) Won't Get Fooled Again A Quick One Yes Close to the Edge Roundabout (the four parts of) Tales from Topographic Oceans And You and I The Gates of Delirium Awaken Zappa, Frank & MoI We're Only in it for the Money Absolutely Free -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Notes: Some groups seem to create music which fits the category fairly often, just as a matter of style. Pink Floyd was the most commonly mentioned group, and I didn't include everything that was suggested. In particular, I left out music from "The Wall", regarding that as a concept album. Yes was also mentioned frequently, as was some of Jon Anderson's solo work. There's a style (perhaps more common in jazz than in rock) in which each musician in a group carries the music for a stretch. Sometimes this leads to the effect I described--two examples which come to mind are the album version of Rare Earth's "Get Ready" and the dread "In-a-Gadda-da-Vida". Rich also commented on this. Another style is simply jamming. The older Allman Brothers albums have examples of this which are also some of the finest old rock there is. (RIP, Duane...) Mike Oldfield was mentioned a couple of times. It fell somewhat outside what I was aiming for in the list. There was little mention of Tangerine Dream--this surprises me. Many of the pieces (say, Stratosfear) are completely one theme, but others (a couple from the album Encore) cover a lot of ground. -- Dick Dunn {hao,ucbvax,allegra}!nbires!rcd (303)444-5710 x3086 ...If you plant ice, you're gonna harvest wind.