evans%Nosc@sri-unix.UUCP (12/05/83)
From: evans@Nosc (Evan C. Evans) Ken Laws in AIList Digest 1:99 states: an adequate answer [to the question of why computers can't see yet] requires a guess at how it is that the human vision system can work in all cases. I cannot answer Ken's question, but perhaps I can provide some useful input. language shapes culture (Sapir-Whorf hypothesis) culture shapes vision (see following) vision shapes language (a priori) The influence of culture on perception (vision) takes many forms. A statistical examination (unpublished) of the British newspaper game "Where's the ball?" is worth consideration. This game has been appearing for some time in British, Australian, New Zealand, & Fijian papers. So far as I know, it has not yet made its ap- pearance in U.S. papers. The game is played thus: A photograph of some common sport involving a ball is published with the ball erased from the picture & the question, where's the ball? Various members of the readership send in their guesses & that closest to the ball's actual position in the unmodified photo wins. Some time back the responses to several rounds of this game were subjected to statistical analysis. This analysis showed that there were statistically valid differences associated with the cultural background of the participants. This finding was particularly striking in Fiji with a resident population comprising several very different cultural groups. Ball placement by the different groups tended to cluster at sig- nificantly different locations in the picture, even for a game like soccer that was well known & played by all. It is unfor- tunate that this work (not mine) has not been published. It does suggest two things: a.) a cultural influence on vision & percep- tion, & b.) a powerful means of conducting experiments to learn more about this influence. For instance, this same research was elaborated into various TV displays designed to discover where children of various age groups placed an unseen object to which an arrow pointed. The children responded enthusiastically to this new TV game, giving their answers by means of a light pen. Yet statistically significant amounts of data were collected ef- ficiently & painlessly. I've constructed the loop above to suggest that none of the three: vision, language, & culture should be studied out of context. E. C. Evans III